Choosing an Italian restaurant in Barrie is about more than just pasta. Too traditional might bore your adventurous partner, while too trendy could feel insincere for an anniversary. Whether it’s a first date over handmade gnocchi or a family celebration with wood-fired pizza, the right spot sets the tone. This updated guide reveals Barrie’s finest Italian destinations for every occasion.
Jimmy Chews [ Primo – Pizza ]
$ | (705) 500-5224 | WEBSITE
![Jimmy Chews [ Primo - Pizza ]](https://onlinefoodrecipes.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Jimmy-Chews-Primo-Pizza-.jpg)
Some pizza cravings demand a certain level of commitment. Jimmy Chews is ideal for diving headfirst into that craving and celebrating your dedication with an equally indulgent double meat pizza. It’s been a local favorite for years, consistently delivering quality pies in a bustling spot in Barrie.
The fact that it draws customers from afar without being a flashy chain says two things: they’re doing something very right with their crispy toppings and tangy sauce, and regulars are trying hard to keep this spot from getting too packed. The busy dining area is lively when it’s evening, but we prefer the focused atmosphere filled with people who are savoring every bite of their Frezzo pizza and enjoying their own conversations.
Casano’s Italian Restaurant and Catering
$ | (705) 737-4752 | WEBSITE
Italian restaurants aren’t typically our first choice for a casual weeknight dinner—we’re not ready for Sal to give us flack on our indecisiveness about pasta shapes. But Casano’s version takes all of the potential stress out of the equation and only keeps the best parts: a menu you don’t have to second-guess, an owner with genuine passion for his cooking, and a welcoming space to really enjoy your meal.
The menu stays consistent, but you can expect hearty homemade Italian dishes influenced by Sal’s family traditions—like the penne with vodka sauce that has just the right creamy kick. Reasonable prices and accommodating service for dietary restrictions make it easy to add this spot to your regular rotation if you’re looking for reliable comfort food.
Bacio Trattoria
$$ | (249) 288-0161 | WEBSITE
Your relationship has survived the first few dates and earned a special occasion dinner. Now it’s time to see if your partner appreciates authentic comfort food. Take them to Bacio Trattoria, a cozy family-run trattoria in Barrie with rustic charm and welcoming service. It’s the perfect setting to discover if your date savors simple pleasures or gets genuinely excited about perfectly executed classics. Between courses, you can enjoy the complementary bread that arrives warm at your table.
There’s a well-priced wine selection to pair with everything, but we’ve particularly enjoyed a crisp white with the chicken parmigiana and a medium-bodied red with the pizza. The chicken parmigiana arrives juicy beneath its crispy coating, while the pizza boasts what might be Barrie’s best crust—perfectly cooked with just the right chew.
There’s also the Cacio Pepe, which delivers fantastic flavor in every creamy bite, or, if you’re still indulging, the pistachio ice cream that’s creamy with perfect nutty flavor.
Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta
$$ | (705) 734-9999 | WEBSITE
Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta feels like it was plucked straight from a classic Italian family film, the kind where everyone gathers around a big wooden table for Sunday supper. It’s got that cozy, neighborhood trattoria vibe going for it, where showing up in your comfiest jeans and a relaxed button-down feels absolutely perfect. The warm lighting and plenty of TVs set the scene for a cinematic dinner for two.
One that’s welcoming, hearty, and should definitely include belly-filling plates of Chicken Parm and Spaghetti Con Polpette. If things go well after your Italian feast, you still have an entire Saturday night ahead full of hanging-out possibilities.
Pizzeria Italia Restaurant
$$ | (705) 728-1421 | WEBSITE
Pizzeria Italia Restaurant is a small Italian spot in Barrie where you can get a bit nostalgic—the takeout window sets you up nicely for sitting close to your family and sharing a large pizza Lady and the Tramp style. Plus, the boxes feature a classic red-and-white checkered print—there’s got to be a memory in there somewhere for you.
Try for an order of that hand-made crust pizza, where you can share loaded toppings and scrumptious meatballs while imagining the kitchen staff tossing dough all night. The menu is also comforting, which is great for an indecisive group. For dessert, share some warm homemade bread paired perfectly with Penne Rose.
Cocelli Pizza
$ | (705) 721-8000 | WEBSITE
By introducing your pizza cravings to Cocelli’s charm, there’s a good chance a regular rotation will be in your near future. This is one of our highest-rated Italian spots, and it’s so good it’ll earn a permanent place in your takeout routine. It’s impossible not to fall for the pies with golden crisp cheese, bowls of spaghetti and meat sauce, decent wings, and perfectly loaded fresh toppings.
The space always has a clean, pleasant energy and works for any meal, really—lunch, dinner, or late-night delivery. Whether you eat at one of the well-maintained tables inside or have it delivered to your door, you can count on one thing: a text the next day to thank you for your order. And if that kind of friendly service doesn’t cinch a return visit, we don’t know what will.
Pizza Pizza
$ | (705) 737-1111 | WEBSITE
Look, not every pizza joint needs to be a gourmet experience. So when you’re craving something straightforward and satisfying, head to Pizza Pizza. There’s plenty to appreciate here—the crispy crust, the loaded toppings, the generous cheese, the friendly delivery service—and the customer service isn’t half bad either. The welcoming atmosphere where workers know regulars by name also gives it a dash of neighborhood charm.
Aside from the classic XL pizza, the gluten-free and plant-based options make a perfect alternative for those with dietary needs. The ol’ loaded-pizza maneuver—a classic straight from the casual dinner playbook.
The Italian Eatery
$ | (705) 733-2697 | WEBSITE
The Italian Eatery is way beyond ordinary takeout territory. This welcoming Barrie destination is for a family celebration, treating the kids to something special, or simply reminding yourself that good food still exists. That’s because there’s no pretentious atmosphere, sterile environment, or rushed service to distract you from the genuine warmth that fills the space. It’s you, your companions, and the sweet aromas of fresh baking that greet you the moment you walk in.
The accommodating staff here will guide you through the menu, offering a variety of Italian classics that might include the Tomato Basil Pasta Penne, a Personal 12″ Pizza, or the delicious veal sandwich. The whole “must-stop for any occasion” feeling is carried through in the market area and homemade meals—they look and taste like they came right from a nonna’s kitchen. Regardless of what you order, it’s going to be a really satisfying meal.
Pizza Nova
$ | (844) 310-3300 | WEBSITE
Pizza Nova is the ultimate pizza night trump card. Why? Because there are few other places where you can brag about liking pizza so much that you jumped through some serious hoops to score a fresh pie. Having said that, you’ll need to be prepared when the lunch rush hits and the orders start piling up. When you finally get your hands on that hot box, you’ll find that the pizza at this Barrie spot is an exciting experience.
Like the perfect balance of sauce, toppings, and crust folded so precisely, they look like one of the owner’s proud creations, and a freshly made pizza that’s the perfect excuse to swap expert eating techniques. Throw some friendly, professional service into the mix, and pretty soon you’ll realize what everyone else does: the wait for that fresh pizza was totally worth it.
147
$$ | (705) 252-9147 | WEBSITE
If there’s one thing Barrie locals can agree on, it’s that stressing over where to celebrate shouldn’t overshadow the occasion itself. That’s why 147 just works. It’s one of those rare spots in town that effortlessly bridges special occasions and casual dining under one roof. You can start with attentive service from staff like Janine in the beautiful party area, which sets the stage for a satisfying meal of braised short rib pasta and gorgonzola gnocchi.
Then, settle into the warm atmosphere for the rest of your evening, whether it’s a milestone dinner or a relaxed night out. It’s the most versatile dining destination in Barrie.