Coral Springs has quietly cultivated a vibrant Italian dining scene that rivals larger Florida cities. While we’re more suburban than urban, this community still knows authentic flavors. From the classic trattorias along University Drive to the modern enotecas in the Town Center, and a growing wave of artisanal pasta spots—these are our favorite Italian restaurants in the city.
Divieto Ristorante – Coral Springs
$$ | (754) 310-2077 | WEBSITE
Why does Divieto Ristorante consistently rank among the most beloved Italian spots in Coral Springs? It’s probably the food, with the Fettuccine Alfredo and lasagna receiving high praise from customers. But it could also be the way the restaurant offers a charming 1920s theme that adds to its overall appeal, alongside the attentive service from servers like Adriana and a friendly manager who personally welcomes guests.
Enjoy Divieto’s new and clean environment with a nice ambiance, whose occasional slower lunch service during quieter hours is one of the few things to note in an otherwise memorable dining experience.
Carrabba’s Italian Grill
$$ | (954) 345-4600 | WEBSITE
Quietly elegant on a typical Tuesday evening, the spacious Coral Springs Italian grill is perfect for family dinners and celebrations, but ideal for the Sunday family feast, that joyful weekly tradition where $25 gets you the Martino menu and all the authentic Italian flavors you can savor in the company of attentive staff and wonderful families.
Along with its kid-friendly atmosphere, the centerpiece of the burgeoning dining scene in Coral Springs, the restaurant’s exceptional service shows that management understands what it’s got here: a culinary treasure.
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
$$ | (954) 344-5226 | WEBSITE
Coral Springs has become a destination for chain dining, but once upon a time, there was a neighborhood spot called Olive Garden—of which this location is the steadfast standard-bearer. Still, the relaxed, amiable restaurant and its unshakeable family-friendly vibe continue to flourish in Coral Springs as it has for years.
Known for going all out on the endless soup, salad, and breadsticks, and for that never-not-satisfying Tour of Italy platter, this restaurant may not serve the trendiest cuisine, but it’s a reliable institution without another Italian option for miles around.
Sarpino’s Pizzeria Coral Springs
$$ | (954) 906-8880 | WEBSITE
Sporting a fresh mural of Italy’s rolling hills, this pizzeria with two dining areas, a proper open kitchen, and a separate takeout counter has never ceded its title as the pre-eminent spot for all kinds of pizza, from classic to vegan to the gluten-free. Humbly offer your server (of any shift) a couple of dollars and hope their hands don’t burn you as they deliver it.
J.R. Pizza Bella Restaurant
$ | (954) 753-1300 | WEBSITE
Open since 2021, J.R. Pizza Bella Restaurant is one of Coral Springs’ most unique Italian-Puerto Rican fusion spots, so naturally, it has a big reputation to uphold. And we’re happy to report that a meal here is still full of garlic rolls, mofongo, and a whole lot of flavor. After a recent renovation, they reopened in their original location and still somehow it feels authentic, even if it’s much livelier and has eclectic Italian decor.
Make sure to check their menu to find the best pizzas, calzones, and pork chop specials around.
La Fontana Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
$ | (954) 575-5502 | WEBSITE
Is it a pizzeria? Is it an Italian restaurant? Well, it’s both and more: a family-owned, family-run establishment named for its signature fountain. But more importantly, La Fontana is a proper trattoria whose kitchen serves Miele e Brie and penne allá vodka en masse, with authentic pizzas, excellent tiramisu, and the ability to make focaccia with pesto feel elegant.
A fountain patio that feels like the piazza section at an Italian festival, a family-friendly ambiance, and staff that treats customers like kin all conspire to make this Coral Springs spot among the most hospitable Italian restaurants in South Florida.
Pepperoni Grill
$ | (954) 345-1604 | WEBSITE
Yeah, yeah, we know: the Pepperoni Grill. But that straightforward name—it’s been serving fresh and delicious Italian food for years, and the patrons skew family-friendly—is one the regulars willingly share. Cozy and inviting, Pepperoni Grill is by extension the best place to sit and watch the increasingly lively Coral Springs dining scene.
Second only to the pricier spots as a place to order a pizza and chat with the owner Michael, it’s also got a kid-friendly environment where you can often smell the chef’s attentive preparations like the off-menu Veal Milanese.
Livello
$$$ | (754) 777-9277 | WEBSITE
Livello, a must-visit Italian restaurant, leaves no room for doubt regarding the near-universal appeal of lobster pasta and diver scallops cooked to perfection. Whether you’re craving homemade pizza or Italian rainbow cookies for dessert, this convivial spot is for everybody, with a menu that changes monthly and a lively atmosphere. Chef Bruno, friendly staff, and hapless souls who were marooned by the wedge salad all fraternize over generous portions at Livello.
AMO Pizzeria
$ | (954) 507-4545 | WEBSITE
As its simple, heartfelt name suggests, AMO Pizzeria is all about genuine Italian cooking, both in the kitchen and in the dining room. Every neighborhood needs a family-run pizzeria, and because it lies within easy reach of Coral Springs’ main thoroughfares, it’s where you’re likeliest to find locals and visitors coming together for a meal.
(And regarding those lunch prices, they’re served with genuine care and they err on the side of being surprisingly fair.) Whether it’s classic Neapolitan pies, a hearty pasta dish, or a true comfort-food experience, this welcoming, family-accented spot is where tried-and-true Italian food enthusiasts can be found.
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings
$ | (954) 340-2625 | WEBSITE
Family-owned since Anthony Bruno opened it in 2002, this Coral Springs staple isn’t exclusively a pizza joint. Rather, it’s more of a neighborhood gathering spot with coal-fired pizzas cooked to perfection and two big draws: a casual interior that feels like it was designed by your favorite uncle who taught you how to enjoy a good meal, and generous portions perfect for the kind of family celebrations you might find in a feel-good movie.
John The Baker Coral Springs
$ | (954) 227-4992 | WEBSITE
Are you a pizza lover? Do you crave that perfect crust? Are you looking for classic Italian comfort food? Do you enjoy marinara sauce that tastes like nostalgia? John The Baker Coral Springs draws a crowd for whom takeout boxes and garlic rolls are the norm. Friendly and consistent, this spot has plenty of customization options and a seal on the pizza box for freshness, but by focusing on classic diner food it’s also the place for families to enjoy great salads and well-made pies.
If you’ve ordered pizza in Coral Springs long enough, your fridge has probably accumulated more than a few of their boxes, too.
Pizza Carousel
$ | (954) 344-2717 | WEBSITE
Pizza Carousel will always be for pizza purists and family diners, with offerings like the classic lunch special and standout combos like tuna fish with pita bread alongside consistently excellent staples like garlic bread, calzone, and the tuxedo dessert. If you like to enjoy incredible salads in the company of friendly staff who can deliver top-notch service with genuine warmth, Pizza Carousel is for you.
Pasquale & Sons’ Pizza Company
$ | (954) 510-0707 | WEBSITE
Pasquale & Sons’ Pizza Company is Coral Springs’ go-to spot for classic Italian-American fare—and really, the only place in the area like it. Come for pizza and a round of wings, and you’ll probably end up sharing a zeppoli or making a new friend (or beyond) at the next table. Unlike other Italian joints in the city, Pasquale & Sons’ is never too pricey, so keep it in mind when you want a casual meal or are in the mood for a low-key night out.
Check their counter for fresh pies, friendly service, and other favorites.
Toscana Pizza & Grill
$$ | (954) 345-4343 | WEBSITE
Hidden gems have been disappearing for years, but few culinary finds are more delightful than the neighborhood Italian-Uruguayan spot. Toscana Pizza & Grill, one of the only authentic blends north or south of Coral Springs, is about as charming as they come. Perhaps best enjoyed after some local errands or on a food crawl through all the eateries on Sample Road with good character—this place has been serving since 2020—Toscana opens at lunch with perfectly crafted pizzas and chivito sandwiches.
And in a city filled with chain restaurants, friendly service and outdoor seating like that may be exactly what keeps this place thriving for years to come.
Incontro Italian Cuisine Steakhouse
$$$ | (754) 547-7997 | WEBSITE
Of course the most romantic spot in Coral Springs sits at the intersection of Italian tradition and steakhouse excellence, each named for a culinary heritage worth celebrating. Having evolved with local tastes, Incontro has transformed from a quiet neighborhood Italian spot where you would find no small amount of homemade pasta to an everyone’s-welcome steakhouse with certain nights featuring live acoustic guitar or violin.
(It’s still romantic, though.) The BYOB policy, while waiting for liquor license renewal, has kept things going these past months but once a special occasion rolls around, expect the Caesar Salads, Chicken Parmigianas, and Frutti Di Mare to shine under the soft lighting at dinners enhanced by staff like Elena and the owner.