Ever found yourself craving a ‘pretty good’ plate of pasta? Me neither. In Lewisville, where every meal feels like a celebration, settling for second-rate rigatoni simply isn’t an option. That’s why we’ve scoured every trattoria and osteria to bring you the definitive list of Italian excellence.
Marinos Italian Pasta & Pizza
$ | (469) 464-3918 | WEBSITE
Marinos Italian Pasta & Pizza is a meal you’ll vividly remember without any help from your camera roll. Their classic Italian dishes (a garlic cheese bread here, amazing stuffed mushrooms there) stay consistent, but standouts, like the fettuccine described as the absolute best and the Philly cheesesteak pizza served with a great cheese quality/mix, remain.
In case this sounds like basic fare, those signature items and others like the chicken Alfredo pizza with its thin crust and generous portions prove otherwise. And all the best neighborhood restaurant tricks are employed here: there’s a welcoming atmosphere (it’s tucked away in Lewisville) and there’s friendly staff, which reveals a front row seat to quick service where the food arrives hot and fresh. The affordable prices and great music make this spot deserve more credit.
Pie 314 Everyday Eatery
$ | (972) 899-2718 | WEBSITE
Pie 314 is like that reliable, go-to spot that’s always there when you need a solid meal with friends. That’s why this cozy Italian eatery draws a mix of crowds—families celebrating Mother’s Day brunch, groups sharing pizzas, and anyone craving a comforting pasta dish. The Margherita pizza is their standout, but everything here, from the spinach artichoke dip to the blueberry ricotta skillet pancake, hits the mark.
This is the type of place that will turn you from a first-timer into a regular, with a favorite outdoor table and a habit of ordering mimosa refills.
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
$ | (972) 315-6202 | WEBSITE
At Olive Garden Italian Restaurant, owned by the chain known for Italian-American classics, traditional comfort food gets served with consistent quality. Pasta dishes come with attentive service and cheesecake comes freshly made. The Italian donuts are the star choice, with hints of sweetness and warmth, and a touch of indulgence. Swing by for family gatherings or for group dinners with ease to enjoy prompt service and hot food.
Old Hag’s Pizza and Pasta
$$ | (972) 999-6899 | WEBSITE
Old Hag’s Pizza and Pasta is bringing the party to Lewisville’s late-night scene. The 24-hour pizza joint is absolutely buzzing on Friday nights with karaoke belting out hits, a lively cafeteria-style space where we’ve seen whole families rocking out, and thin-crust pies that deserve a few extra slices. Every giant table feels like a prime spot for a group hang or a pizza-fueled family outing.
The meatball and onion with jalapeños is a great showcase of their range—from the bold and fiery Porky the Hag (this pepperoni and sausage mix is a must) to the sweet and tangy Mulberry—but everything here is so solid that it tastes like they baked it fresh just for you. The servers are chill, the food comes out fast, and you can hang as long as you want without anyone rushing you out the door.
Nick’s Pizza & Pasta, Inc.
$ | (972) 317-4344 | WEBSITE
Finding a great pizza joint, even in a town full of them, isn’t usually a challenge in these parts. But Nick’s Pizza & Pasta remains the area’s hardest-to-resist comfort food, so grabbing a table at the cozy 40-seat dining room in Denton County is the ultimate casual night out. The space is equally welcoming—a simple storefront leads to a bright room that looks like the only way to enter is with a smile and a craving for cheesy goodness.
Servers, dressed in casual attire, blend into the homey atmosphere until one steps forward to take your order. But the biggest decision to make will be which of the signature dishes will be your favorite, especially when every bite of that crispy-crust pizza is worthy of the title.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (972) 221-5200 | WEBSITE
At Marco’s Pizza in Lewisville, “basic” might be a dirty word. Red-checkered tablecloths drape over sturdy wooden tables, vintage pizza peel signs hang on exposed brick walls, and the scent of baking dough and melting cheese might make you hungry before you order. Everything is ready-made for a casual meal when you want the food to do the satisfying. But still, the brilliant pizzas here refuse to be upstaged.
A perfectly balanced Deluxe arrives with a crisp, golden crust and bubbling with fresh mushrooms, onions, and jalapenos. And the cauliflower crust, a gluten-free classic, lands on your table like a customizable canvas with your choice of dairy-free toppings.
D’Nonna
$$ | (469) 240-0008 | WEBSITE
In the world of Italian dining, this cozy Lewisville gem stands out from the crowd. And that’s why this place stays packed, so arrive early or during the weekday lunch hour when you can slip into one of the warm wooden booths without a reservation. We’ve visited multiple times, savoring the rich chicken marsala and pillowy three-cheese gnocchi while trying to find a pattern in the beautiful brickwork and rustic décor. We’ve come up empty.
But we do think they should install a golden pasta sculpture to celebrate their consistently excellent, wonderfully satisfying gluten-free options.
Rosati’s Pizza – Lewisville
$$ | (469) 702-0055 | WEBSITE
If you love deep dish and hearty portions and have about twenty bucks to spare, make your way to Rosati’s Pizza. The cozy, Chicago-style pizzeria in Lewisville only serves a few classic dishes, but that doesn’t stop the friendly staff from delivering quick, warm service that makes you feel right at home. It’s comforting, we promise. Rosati’s specializes in unbeatable deep dish pizza—crispy crust, rich sauce, and gooey cheese.
And even though it’s a hefty slice, the perfectly balanced flavors nearly melt in your mouth.
Viva La Pasta
$ | (972) 537-5057 | WEBSITE
Viva La Pasta does some really satisfying things with its reliably consistent menu. So while you’ll fall in love with dishes like the shrimp and chicken pasta with its rich mixed Alfredo and tomato sauce, paired perfectly with a side of clam chowder and rolls, you’ll likely find yourself craving them again and again. But that’s more reason to return.
They don’t overcomplicate things here—the atmosphere is warm and inviting, with attentive servers and managers who ensure everything runs smoothly, all in a cozy, friendly environment where the portions are large and the wait time is reasonable. Plus, we love that we can sink into the lively, welcoming setting after polishing off amazing bread, mozzarella sticks, or a slice of their flavorful pizza.
Bistecca – An Italian Steakhouse
$$$ | (972) 318-0515 | WEBSITE
Bistecca truly shines as a celebration destination, where the excellent ambience transforms a meal into a memorable event. The Italian steakhouse menu is consistently outstanding, with incredible steaks that arrive perfectly cooked and innovative desserts like the made-to-order soufflé that’s worth every minute of anticipation.
There are classic options, like the steak and lobster tail with Gorgonzola butter that balances richness with a hint of sharpness, and the garlic mashed potatoes that are creamy without being heavy. Yes, familiar dishes but executed with such care and attention that they feel special. And you should savor them, especially in the warmly lit dining room, where attentive staff ensure water glasses stay full and plates are cleared promptly, though the space can run a bit cool for some.
It’s the kind of place where you’ll already be planning your next visit with friends before the strawberry cheesecake even arrives.
Palio’s Pizza Cafe castle hills
$$ | (972) 300-0132 | WEBSITE
Palio’s Pizza Cafe castle hills delivers consistently satisfying Italian-American classics with just the right touch of casual comfort. Pizza arrives with a perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings, and the acidity of the side salad cuts through the richness of the full-topping pies. But it all starts with the lunch special—a deliciously complete $11 deal that includes a small pizza, a salad, and a drink.
The family-friendly Castle Hills spot is never too hectic, so it feels like you’ve found a reliable neighborhood gem—it’s the place for a quick, enjoyable meal with the kids or for just hanging out with friends.