Aurora, IL, has so many pizza joints, there’s even one (for better or worse) that delivers by drone. These pizza experiences can be some of the most satisfying in town—but they can also be the most overpriced, with $30+ pies becoming standard at artisanal spots. That’s where this guide comes in.
Gourmet Pizza Corporation
$ | (630) 897-2242 | WEBSITE
The thin-crust pizza at Gourmet Pizza Corporation (yes, in Aurora) is the neighborhood’s best option for a classic pie. You might get a sausage pizza with green peppers and melty cheese, or crispy chicken wings fried until golden brown. Come here with your family, snag a table with ample parking nearby, and enjoy it all with whatever soda the friendly staff suggests.
Nancy’s Pizza
$ | (630) 585-9600 | WEBSITE
The classic cheese pizza at Nancy’s is an efficient way to try what makes this Aurora pizza joint’s reputation, including the perfectly melted mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and crispy crust that comes together like it’s been practicing for decades. Slices lean on the generous side, so consider sharing with at least one topping, like the savory, pepperoni-studded special. If you’re customizing your order, the price is the same as the standard menu option.
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
$ | (630) 575-8500 | WEBSITE
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria in Aurora offers a classic deep dish experience that’s become a local institution. That signature pie arrives with a buttery crust and layers of cheese and toppings, whether you’re digging into the Personal Mikes Hot Honey or sharing a Medium Pepperoni pizza. But the real draw is the consistently friendly service from staff like Nancy P., who makes first-timers feel like regulars.
The dining area feels cozy and welcoming, with sturdy wooden tables that invite lingering over your meal. Keep this spot in mind for a family dinner that’s more satisfying than delivery but doesn’t require dressing up or making reservations weeks in advance.
Amato’s Pizza
$ | (630) 236-0055 | WEBSITE
The pizza joint in Aurora is a lunchtime destination to plan for a quick work break—and a place to swing by on a whim for a slice and a soda. This isn’t a fancy sit-down spot serving deep-dish pies or elaborate toppings. Here you’ll get things like pepperoni and sausage slices with unrivaled crust, thin-crust pizza with giardinera and onions, and daily specials like two slices for $8 on Mondays, all served on paper plates you might find at a casual neighborhood spot down the street.
There’s also a $9 combo lunch special that comes with pepperoni and sausage slices. And, like the regular menu, it stays consistent with what customers crave.
Santis Pizza
$ | (630) 299-3846 | WEBSITE
At Santis Pizza, the pepperoni pizza gets a savory kick from a generous sprinkle of aged mozzarella, and wings are tossed in a tangy garlic-parmesan sauce. Like the classic offerings, this pizza joint in Aurora punches up its pies with fresh, quality ingredients. It’s a straightforward spread of everything from a loaded meat-lover’s pizza and crispy buffalo wings to a gooey chocolate chip cookie for dessert.
This cozy space is filled with red-checkered tables and warm pendant lighting, and is where you’ll want to spend hours catching up with friends and debating the best pizza toppings. Just keep the ice-cold sodas and garlic knots coming.
the PIAZZA – Aurora
$$ | (630) 978-2088 | WEBSITE
The pizza at The Piazza runs about $25 for a large pie, which feels like a steal considering the excellent quality you get all night. Since this Aurora spot is the legendary venue that offers a unique experience, it’s no surprise that it knocks the atmosphere out of the park. The visit kicks off with the impressive building and cool, friendly staff.
You’ll then dive into more offerings like the good pizza, the rare cigar lounge where you can smoke inside, and dedicated entertainment like sports, live music, and events—with Summer’s Last Dance praised as outstanding. The evening goes down in a space with a great vibe, lit up by the VIP area’s clean environment and excellent sight lines—ideal for big-deal nights out that require the fun levels to be turned up to max.
Pub 56
$ | (630) 299-3429 | WEBSITE
At Pub 56, $12 gets you a fantastic chicken Alfredo, oftentimes with a bonus breadstick or two. The menu selection stays consistent, but count yourself lucky if you get a piece of tasty sirloin paired with a cold draft beer or the crispy fish and chips. While this family-friendly bar doesn’t offer much for fine dining atmosphere, you can’t find a better deal for watching sports with great food anywhere else in Aurora.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (630) 264-4444 | WEBSITE
Domino’s Pizza in Aurora offers one of the best value delivery experiences in town. For $18, you get a large pepperoni pizza with efficient service that will easily satisfy whatever pizza craving brought you here. This family-friendly spot also accommodates special requests like using a clean blade to avoid cross-contamination. Whichever option you choose, know that you can also track your order through the app to round out your experience.
We like the friendly delivery drivers, who go above and beyond with pleasant service, and the overall positive atmosphere that keeps customers coming back.
Little Pops NY Pizzeria Express
$ | (630) 687-9400 | WEBSITE
Head to Little Pops NY Pizzeria Express for pizza that won’t break the bank. The slices feel like a full meal: the cheese slice comes with a shareable zucchini sticks side, and the Lasagna pizza rolls deep with a crew of fresh ingredients, light crispy crust, and flavor that mimics the satisfaction of a sit-down dinner.
There’s also a $5.99 slice and drink combo, but if you’re there during the summer months, the outdoor seating is likely serving a slice or two of Margherita pizza to ply you into repeat visits.
Lady T’s Pizzeria & Pub
$ | (630) 820-7447 | WEBSITE
While Lady T’s Pizzeria & Pub offers a wide range of delicious options, you’ll end up with a full table as each pizza is generously sized and perfect for sharing. It’s a great way to feed a hungry group, which should really be the point here, considering every dish makes good use of quality ingredients that come together in satisfying combinations.
On a recent visit, we enjoyed crispy Mozz sticks with marinara, a loaded pizza topped with fresh vegetables and pepperoni, and boneless chicken with a side salad that reminded us of the perfect game-day snack. Their signature quesadillas are also always available and perfect for taking home for later.