It’s easy to overlook Fairfield’s pizza scene. It’s overshadowed by big-city legends, and the chain slice you grab on the go tastes like cardboard. But when you crave something real, something that reminds you why this town deserves a second look, head to one of these spots. At these 12 pizzerias, you’ll find chewy crusts, bubbling cheese, and the simple joy of a perfect pie—proof that great pizza doesn’t need a New York address.
Straw Hat Pizza
$$ | (707) 421-8300 | WEBSITE
The pizza scene in Fairfield can get pretty intense, with folks debating New York-style authenticity like it’s a matter of civic pride. When you need a break from all that, head to Straw Hat. We aren’t going to claim this spot serves the absolute best pizza in the county. That kind of talk feels out of place here. (Though, honestly, you could probably make the case.) Straw Hat is just Straw Hat.
It’s a no-fuss joint in a large, open dining space where friendly-enough staff have been serving up consistently solid pies for years. The cheese is melty, the lights are bright, and the crunch on that crust is, yes, exactly right.
Cenario’s Pizza of Cordelia
$ | (707) 864-6400 | WEBSITE
By design, a visit to Cenario’s Pizza of Cordelia takes you out of your ordinary pizza routine: this family-owned spot with a spacious atmosphere and some of the best stuffed crust pies in Fairfield is the perfect excuse to skip the chain restaurants and indulge in something real.
Grab a seat in the roomy dining area and settle in for a hearty meal of pizza classics, like a personal cheese pizza with that crispy-tender crust, or daily favorites, like the medium chicken garlic pizza loaded with generous toppings. If your weeknight dinner needs a little shaking up too, take home some of their hot and fluffy breadsticks—they’re a great side for any pizza you want to enjoy, all at affordable prices that won’t break the bank.
New York Pizza Express
$ | (707) 399-8802 | WEBSITE
Perhaps the most satisfying perk of living in Fairfield is how reliably you can get a big, cheesy slice of pizza when the craving hits. There are plenty of spots where you can point at toppings through the glass, but one of our go-tos is this unassuming family-owned joint, which has been a local favorite for years, though it feels like it’s been here forever.
The owners deliver fast, friendly service with unbeatable prices, while their signature pizzas—like the BBQ Louisiana and classic cheese—keep customers coming back. This place has all the straightforward, no-fuss charm you want from a neighborhood pizza spot, without any pretension. Get whichever pie the regulars keep raving about, and you won’t be disappointed.
Vicini’s New York City Pizzeria
$ | (707) 425-2600 | WEBSITE
Vicini’s New York City Pizzeria sits in the Riley’s / CVS shopping center, a spot that’s been serving slices since it opened. The owner’s Staten Island roots ensure every pie tastes like it came straight from the five boroughs. If you come here for one thing, it should be the pizza with vodka sauce, but you should never just get one thing. Where else can you experience the beauty of a fresh, crunchy salad alongside those mouth-watering garlic knots?
The small indoor space feels cozy rather than cramped, with a clean and lively environment that makes you want to stay for dessert—the homemade cheesecake and cannoli are worth every calorie. At around $25 for a large pie, it’s a steal for authentic New York-style pizza with a thin crust that’s both flavorful and satisfying. The staff is very nice, adding to the friendly atmosphere that keeps locals and visitors coming back.
Cenario’s Pizza of Fairfield
$ | (707) 425-1000 | WEBSITE
Grabbing a pizza from Cenario’s after a long day feels like slipping into your favorite hoodie and settling in for a movie marathon—it’s just that comforting. There’s something so satisfying about ordering from this Italian-style spot in Fairfield. They don’t need a complicated menu—when you call, you’ll hear about the fresh toppings you’ll be enjoying later that evening. Their options stay consistent, but no matter what, go for the veg pizza and make sure to ask for extra cheese on the side.
Cenario’s isn’t the only pizza place in Fairfield, but it’s a bit quicker than the others, save for the families picking up multiple boxes to share around the kitchen table.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (707) 422-3100 | WEBSITE
According to the timeline, Little Caesars Pizza was founded in 1959 in Garden City, Michigan. A few decades later, the chain expanded across the country. Today, you can still stop by the Fairfield location—now offering mobile orders—and enjoy a very straightforward pizza experience that consists of quick service with a 5-20 minute wait. Would you like some Crazy Puffs? No trick question. They’re the standout item.
The lunch special is emphatic: You must have the deep dish pizza with a drink for $5.99, a good deal that fills you up without emptying your wallet. The stuffed crust pizza provides a familiar chew, and a side of buffalo wings will help balance your meal as you navigate the small, busy space at the compact counter.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (707) 425-4456 | WEBSITE
Domino’s Pizza, a reliable chain spot on Fairfield’s main drag, is the kind of place where you can pull up in your car, place an order from your phone, and be reminded of the simple pleasure of a well-executed pizza night.
It’s been a staple in American neighborhoods for decades, and there’s something about biting into their crispy thin crust, loaded with generous toppings, or their perfectly hand-tossed dough, that leads to thoughts about how families from all over town might have gathered here, after a long week of school and work.
The menu of customizable pizzas and sides is straightforward, but it’s overshadowed by the sense of efficiency and care that the staff, from the counter to the delivery drivers, bring to every order.
Pizza Twist
$ | (707) 366-0006 | WEBSITE
If you’ve ever ordered pizza in Fairfield, like even one time, you’ve probably experienced the disappointment that can be even attempting to find something different. That’s one of many reasons we love Pizza Twist. The walk-in-only restaurant is quiet enough for a solo weeknight meal, convenient enough for a late-night craving, and helpful enough for dietary restrictions, except when it’s after midnight, because the staff is still there serving. Other than that though, stroll in anytime.
They make, they serve, and the pizza is a little bit Indian, a little bit traditional, and a little bit whatever you want to order that day, like vegan pizza with crispy crust, or wings when you’re hungry. Try those, but always get the Indian-style pizza.
Chuck E. Cheese
$$ | (707) 241-4004 | WEBSITE
If it’s quiet date nights and candlelit dinners that put fine dining on your sh*t list, Chuck E. Cheese is pretty much as far removed from those as you can get. The family entertainment center is in Fairfield, so you can combine a visit with some shopping, or a movie, depending on the mood. Once the arcade games have washed away your stress, walk through the doors to Chuck E.
Cheese, where you’ll find some of the area’s most comforting, satisfying food, like crispy pepperoni pizza, and flavorful chicken wings. With your stomach full and your kids entertained—by way of cheesy bread, and the cheerful staff like Javier and manager Ally—you’ll be ready to once again go back to ignoring the nightly chaos of bedtime routines.
Mountain Mike’s Pizza
$ | (707) 864-1700 | WEBSITE
It’s not quite artisanal wood-fired, but at Mountain Mike’s Pizza, the distance from oven to table is about thirty seconds. Since 1978, the Mountain Mike’s chain has kept families’ dinner tables stocked with reliable pizza. Their cheerful Fairfield location, which opened in 2020, uses a tasty blend of mozzarella, sauce, and fresh dough. You can also build your own pizza from the buffet line and have it baked on the spot for no extra fee.
The excellent salad bar costs extra during the lunch buffet, but the top-tier family atmosphere is on the house.
Evelyn’s Big Italian
$ | (707) 421-9000 | WEBSITE
It could be your cousin, your coworker, or your kid’s soccer coach, but someone you know has celebrated a birthday or team party at this Italian spot, and raves about their massive 32-inch pizza, loaded with generous toppings and baked to order in that classic passage oven. Inside, the historical ambiance wraps you in warmth, with cozy booths filling up with families and professionals who have been sharing plates of spaghetti and stromboli in this exact spot for years.
Come for huge portions of New York-style classics, friendly staff who make you feel right at home, and a general feeling that a good meal with good people still matters. A lot has changed in Fairfield, but Evelyn’s Big Italian remains.
Mary’s Pizza Shack
$ | (707) 422-2700 | WEBSITE
A pizza joint that’s also a family tradition, Mary’s Pizza Shack has been a fixture in Fairfield’s dining scene for years. Brightly decorated with sports memorabilia, chalkboard specials, and pizza-themed art, it’s part-playground and part-neighborhood pub, with some practical touches, like tables covered in easy-clean laminate. The servers, including Dominic, are also the guides, and they’ll come over to explain the build-your-own options, then head back to the kitchen to fire up your pie.
With straightforward, satisfying pies, partly made to order, this is above all just a place to unwind with your crew. You won’t be hurried along—if anything you might linger over a second beer on a busy night—so grab a couple of friends, and settle in for a meal that’s the antidote to all those overly fussy restaurant experiences.