Has your search for the perfect slice in Fredericton left you hungry for more? Did you just realize that your craving for authentic wood-fired Neapolitan can’t be satisfied by the usual spots? Sounds like a Pizza Problem. Whether you’re after a classic New York-style fold or an artisanal pie topped with local ingredients, check out these Fredericton pizzerias that are serving up the best in 2026.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (506) 449-5050 | WEBSITE
Yes, this is another pizza restaurant in Fredericton, and yes, this is another Domino’s location too. We can’t help that those two attributes make for a great last-minute meal option. Even more so when you add unbeatable deals to the mix. Domino’s Pizza has a straightforward ordering process that can be configured in different ways, including online options with vegetarian choices that cater to various needs.
The pizza is consistently delicious, and you can customize the menu (along with the crust and the garlic fingers) for your order.
Jack’s Pizza
$ | (506) 443-9000 | WEBSITE
If your idea of a perfect late-night meal involves something more satisfying than a sad frozen pizza, chances are you’re going to need a spot that delivers both flavor and fun. Lucky for you, Jack’s Pizza has exactly what you’re craving. The vibe here has personality—you can grab a slice in the lively main area with its colorful lights and upbeat music, or find a slightly quieter corner to catch up with friends.
The pizza has personality too—Jack’s offers classics done right, with crispy thin crust, fresh toppings, and that famous Donair sauce that adds a tangy, creamy kick. A late-night bite in a place that’s buzzing, welcoming, and filled with the smell of baking dough sure beats another boring night in.
Little Caesars Pizza
$$ | (506) 450-5653 | WEBSITE
Little Caesars Pizza is one of our go-to spots in the city—the Fredericton location has been around for years, but the pizza is still satisfying enough to keep us coming back. They do affordable family-friendly pizza with quick-service twists (like the hearty Deep Dish pizza) and maintain consistent staples (like the classic pepperoni) on the menu. You can choose to have these pies served take-out only from the counter in the bright, casual space of the restaurant.
Luna Pizza
$ | (506) 455-4020 | WEBSITE
Yes, another pizza joint on this list. But this beloved Fredericton spot on the south side seems tailor-made for family dinners and enjoying Very Casual Meals in a cozy setting with friendly staff and complimentary salads. The pizzas are great, and the menu also has things like gluten-free options and a slightly sweeter sauce so distinctive it’s remembered for decades.
There are busy times to navigate too, if a quick bite isn’t a concern and you want to experience the full effect of Luna’s Montreal-style heritage and crusts baked to crispy perfection for over 25 years.
El Mariachi Restaurant Bar
$$ | (506) 454-2800 | WEBSITE
Like everything in the Mexican dining scene, El Mariachi Restaurant Bar is a fun spot with solid food. You’ll find authentic Mexican dishes with highlights—like the top-notch quesadillas—plus options with variety, like the really good tacos. The venue is large and can accommodate big groups, but you’ll probably want to invite fewer people because that means more tacos left for you.
New England Pizza Company
$ | (506) 459-5400 | WEBSITE
New England Pizza Company is a very straightforward, pizza-focused spot in Fredericton that’s been around for a while, and you probably only remember that it exists when you’re craving a solid square-shaped pie. In fact, maybe this time it’ll be the late-night takeout run that you’re in charge of for some reason. New England Pizza Company has multiple options for whatever the craving and occasion.
You can decide on a classic pizza with that cream cheese stuffed crust everyone talks about, garlic fingers that are some of the best around, or maybe that half pound donair they say is the best in eastern Canada, with an extra sauce on the side for the perfect flavor.
Milda’s Pizzas + More
$ | (506) 206-6990 | WEBSITE
Milda’s Pizzas + More is the third of twenty pizza spots featured in this Fredericton guide. But love it or hate it, Fredericton has some great pizza joints. Milda’s is always a cozy spot (helped by warm lighting and wooden furnishings), with delicious pizzas like margarita, feta+pesto, and the popular “3 little pigs.” It’s even better when you’re enjoying that pizza in a charming basement space with 30 of your closest friends, or 30 not-so-close colleagues.
If you hate crowds, noise, or other lively things in life, there’s a quieter corner that seats about 15 people as well.
Papa Georgio’s Pizza
$ | (506) 452-7272 | WEBSITE
We told you Fredericton was known for its pizza spots. Out of all the local joints, Papa Georgio’s is the most beloved. It’s perfect for experiencing all the things people love about this town. Not only does it have fantastic pizza with classic sides, but the atmosphere is cozy and the walls have nostalgic photos adding to its charm.
There are plenty of affordable options to choose from, and you can start enjoying as early as lunch—because everyone in Fredericton knows a satisfying meal includes a generous fish and chips platter for under ten dollars.
Greco Pizza
$ | (506) 454-3030 | WEBSITE
For a spot that’s reliable and straightforward but not lacking in character, check out Greco Pizza. This pizza place on Dundonald Street is convenient and has great food, like the must-order classic pizzas that are consistently tasty and satisfying. Besides the food, a big draw is their friendly service—the staff are always helpful and add personal touches, like jokes on pizzas, which make the experience more enjoyable.
The location offers easy parking and remains a trusted place for quality pizza and welcoming service.
Boston Pizza
$$ | (506) 454-3344 | WEBSITE
Boston Pizza is everything we like about a family-friendly pizza chain combined with everything we like about Fredericton dining. That means varied and delicious food (including customizable pasta, chicken mushroom Alfredo, kids’ spaghetti, and a unique cotton candy dairy drink), friendly service from standout employees like Connie and Anna, and a busy atmosphere.
You can enjoy a rushed but attentive meal in the main dining room, or navigate the challenging parking situation that comes with its popularity.
Coastline Pizza
$$ | (506) 459-3781 | WEBSITE
Coastline Pizza feels like Mad Libs: Fredericton Pizzeria Edition—you can eat Detroit style deep dish alongside shaved Brussel sprouts and drink a cold Half Cut beer while enjoying bright and fresh toppings in a shared microbrewery space. And this Northside spot delivers on every fill-in-the-blank aspect of a great pizza, especially the crust that spans crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and toppings like tender hoisin pork.
There’s a wonderful atmosphere in the main area, or you can try the Puttanesca pizza for a transcendental choice that masquerades as a special.
Tony Pepperoni Gourmet Pizza – Fredericton South Side
$ | (506) 449-3333 | WEBSITE
Tony Pepperoni Gourmet Pizza has been a Fredericton South Side favorite for years, and it’s a local staple for a reason. This pizza spot does it up right—right-sized portions, right-on flavors with fresh ingredients, and right-at-home vibes from the amazingly kind and super friendly staff.
Their cozy, clean location is a great option for family dinners, gatherings, or any occasion that might involve sharing a BBQ chicken pizza or digging into what they proudly call the best stuffed crust in Canada.
Pizza Delight
$ | (506) 459-1707 | WEBSITE
If you have a family-friendly pizza restaurant bucket list, Pizza Delight is probably on it. Of course, being featured in a ’20 Best Pizza Restaurants’ guide doesn’t necessarily mean a place is worth your time—but Pizza Delight definitely is. There are children’s parties and family gatherings to choose from, and that’s where your decision-making will end, thanks to their fresh, tender-crust pizza with generous toppings and excellent super donair.
Consider their welcoming atmosphere when you have a real need to celebrate a birthday perfectly.
Fadi’s Pizza & Donair
$ | (506) 454-9888 | WEBSITE
Historically, our favorite way to enjoy Fadi’s is for a casual solo takeout that involves the best pizza in Fredericton. But sharing an 18″ Works pizza with up to six of our friends sounds pretty good too. Generous slices of crispy-crusted pizza are served piping hot for about $25 for a large.
And if that isn’t satisfying enough for your Friday night craving, there’s always the all-meat pizza with its unique nostalgic sauce available through Fadi’s community-minded approach that supports local organizations.
East Side Mario’s
$$ | (506) 455-3636 | WEBSITE
East Side Mario’s is a family-friendly pizza spot with some of the best service in Fredericton, and it feels like a party. Bring the kids (or a few) for your next casual dinner, and get ready for all those delicious-looking sausage pepper penne, wedding soup, and fish and chips you saw on the menu to be yours.
Gisele’s Pizzeria Northside
$$ | (506) 206-4000 | WEBSITE
At first glance, Gisele’s Pizzeria Northside feels like a place that’s trying very hard to be the neighborhood favorite—the walls are covered in local sports memorabilia and the check comes in a vintage pizza box. Underneath the charmingly cluttered exterior though, this pizzeria is serving seriously great pizza, and you can enjoy it with fewer distractions in their cozy corner booth. That booth seats four, and it will only get as noisy as the number of families celebrating birthdays around you.
It’s a good option when you want to ease into having a satisfying meal, and maybe grab some takeout for later on the way home.
Pepper Creek Pizza Fredericton
$ | (506) 454-9866 | WEBSITE
Pepper Creek Pizza Fredericton has all the traits of a typical family-owned spot: it’s cozy, clean, and has friendly staff. But it’s also a really good pizza restaurant with great pies, platters, and softball-sized naked wings. Grab one of their comfortable booths for a casual meal with 4-6 people. Or try their welcoming main dining area—you’ll be able to relax more easily when your favorite server brings you their superb donair sub and swarm pizza that everyone’s talking about.
Pizza Hut
$ | (506) 450-9988 | WEBSITE
For $12 per person, you can enjoy a satisfying meal for up to six of your favorite people at Pizza Hut, one of our go-to spots in Fredericton. If you’re just grabbing a quick bite with a couple of friends, you can order a medium pizza instead. There’s a variety of excellent dishes like smokey maple bacon pizza with stuffed crust, wings, and onion rings, which means more eating and less debate about what to order.
Pizza Pizza
$ | (506) 300-1111 | WEBSITE
Fredericton is known for pizza spots, and there’s a 99% chance that someone you know will want to grab a slice at one. Pizza Pizza is a solid choice. The food is great, and it’s consistently impressive with its fresh ingredients and meticulous preparation. The attentive, friendly staff ensures every visit is a pleasure—a perfect backdrop to celebrate your friend’s accomplishment of finding the best butter chicken pizza in town.
Pricing starts at $15-$25 per person and will get you things like the uniquely delicious Butter Chicken Pizza with its tender chicken and rich, creamy sauce, or the flavorful creamy garlic dipping sauce.
Papa John’s Pizza
$$ | (506) 474-7272 | WEBSITE
At some point during a meal here, everyone experiences what we call ‘The Papa John’s Moment’—the inevitable realization that this place is surprisingly satisfying. The freshly baked Works Pizza could make it happen. Or it could be the good promotions they often offer. So if you want to go down in history as hosting the most convenient of dinners, order from this pizza spot.
The menu focuses on classic pies and provides enough options to rival a Choose Your Own Adventure, but with more cheese and toppings.