Who serves the perfect slice in Lewisville? Our team debated this fiercely. After countless taste tests, many napkins stained with sauce, and heated discussions about crusts, we present this definitive 2026 guide to the city’s best pizza. Whether you crave New York-style foldable slices, swear by deep-dish decadence, or prefer wood-fired artistry, this list delivers.
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
$$ | (972) 459-9700 | WEBSITE
This Lewisville brewhouse’s Pizookie brownie dessert has the heft of a softball and is topped with a melty scoop of vanilla ice cream. It’s also part of the $12 special all day—so feel free to indulge in as many as you can handle after finishing your parmesan crusted chicken or shrimp Alfredo.
Mountain Mike’s Pizza
$ | (972) 954-2004 | WEBSITE
We could easily pick that 20″ classic pepperoni pizza out of a lineup—and that’s not just because the entire thing is topped with those little round pepperonis that get a little crispy. This pizza joint’s version has a smoky backbone with richness from the generous helping of quality toppings. Also, it’s around $13 for the lunch buffet, for all the quick-lunch seekers out there.
Chuck E. Cheese
$$ | (972) 315-6260 | WEBSITE
The pizza at Chuck E. Cheese is consistently fresh and delicious. There’s enough flavor to satisfy adults, while maintaining a kid-friendly appeal that makes each slice a little different. We also love the hidden reservoirs of melty cheese in the cheesy bread.
Minchello’s pizzeria
$ | (972) 459-5565 | WEBSITE
Minchello’s—tucked away in a mall food court—clearly knows how to do more than just affordable slices. What we love most about their pepperoni thin crust pizza is the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The fresh and tasty pie with no soggy bottom doesn’t hurt either. Neither does the fact that this pizza, despite being authentic East Coast-style, still has enough chew to make your taste buds work for it.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (972) 353-4400 | WEBSITE
As one of the best pizza spots in Lewisville, it should come as no surprise that this local favorite also makes a great triple pepperoni magnifico pizza. Their version is so loaded with toppings that it’s almost overflowing, and layered with savory pepperoni slices. But the fresh, real ingredients and excellent service ensure the experience doesn’t go downhill, even on snowy icy days when they deliver exactly what customers are craving.
Papa Johns Pizza
$ | (469) 240-5779 | WEBSITE
It’s no secret that we love Papa Johns, the Lewisville pizzeria and pizza icon. And that adoration extends to their signature pie, which has a perfectly crisp crust and almost caramelized edges. Plus, the toppings are generously distributed throughout the pizza, so every slice hits you over the head with flavor.
Motor City Pizza
$ | (972) 654-6276 | WEBSITE
This Lewisville pizzeria’s crust is so thick and crusty we’re not even sure it came from a regular oven. That signature thick crust really gives the toppings the spotlight—the base is perfectly balanced, so each pop of flavor jumps out. The regular crust holds its own too, offering a delicious change from your everyday pizza. We also tried the lemon pepper wings and berry sanders drink, both thoroughly enjoyable.
With friendly, attentive staff creating a welcoming family atmosphere, it’s easy to see why this place earns high marks for both food and service.
Nick’s Pizza & Pasta, Inc.
$ | (972) 317-4344 | WEBSITE
The star attraction at this Denton County pizza joint is the giant size pizza. But the hidden gem is the lobster ravioli, which gets a boost of flavor from the house dressing and is topped off with a sprinkle of fresh herbs.
Rosati’s Pizza – Lewisville
$$ | (469) 702-0055 | WEBSITE
Say what you will, but sometimes depth does matter—and in this case, it’s especially important because the generous layers mean you’ll get to spend more precious time with this “unbeatable” deep dish (their word, but we agree). The pizza has a lot going for it beyond the depth, though. There’s a crispy crust with a rich sauce and enough gooey cheese to ensure you taste it in each bite.
Amore’s Italian Restaurant
$ | (469) 702-2010 | WEBSITE
We have yet to find anything that Amore’s Italian Restaurant doesn’t nail, and the mushroom tortellini alfredo is no exception. It’s rich and creamy, like it’s been simmered for hours, but don’t let the decadent sauce deceive you—there’s still a freshness to every bite, complete with tender pasta.