In Peabody, the crisp New England air does more than just signal autumn—it creates the perfect appetite for pizza. When that first chill bites, nothing satisfies like a steaming slice from a wood-fired oven. Whether you crave a classic Neapolitan pie or a loaded Boston-style square, this updated guide leads you to the cheesy, crusty perfection you’re craving.
The Double Bull
$$ | (978) 817-3670 | WEBSITE
The drinks at The Double Bull in Peabody taste like every cocktail was mixed up to order from fresh ingredients, as if the blueberries were plucked from the bush right in front of you. With options like hard cider, blueberry beer, and delicious cocktails, The Double Bull embraces casual and fun contingencies in a bright, clean space. Order the BBQ wings and chimichurri shrimp and admire the surrounding arcade games and dartboards.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (978) 536-3100 | WEBSITE
You’ll find Domino’s Pizza in a bustling commercial area where parking can be a challenge due to tight spaces and unclear lines. There’s a straightforward menu that meets expectations, but with the friendly and accommodating staff eager to deliver food even before you arrive at the parking lot, you can create a meal tailored to your pizza cravings.
Maybe you want a classic pepperoni and cheese combination, or perhaps you prefer something reliable, like a hand-tossed pizza with extra toppings to fill your order. And while the restaurant is clean inside, the credit card processing system can sometimes add unexpected tip charges, so plan to check your receipt carefully.
Brazilian Hotdog pizza & Burger
$ | (978) 531-0992 | WEBSITE
Brazilian Hotdog Pizza & Burger is Peabody’s hottest pizza joint, functioning like a weekly hype sneaker drop, but, you know, if those sneakers were piping-hot Brazilian pies. The cozy spot in town makes a rotating selection of specialties—like chicken pizza with catupiry and pepperoni, or picanha—selling them through its online shop. Regulars log on early, and once the orders open, nearly all the day’s pizzas are snatched up in a matter of minutes. Move fast.
Atha’s Roast Beef & Pizza
$ | (978) 536-9915 | WEBSITE
There are several pizza spots in Peabody, and Atha’s Roast Beef & Pizza looks like a straightforward neighborhood joint. Inside, alongside the hum of the kitchen, there are generous portions of consistently good beef and standout onion rings.
Get the superb Regular Beef 3 Way with its tender, melt-in-your-mouth beef and zingy BBQ sauce, keep it classic with a couple slices of thin crust pizza, and add a questionable number of toppings and then settle in at a simple table to enjoy your meal, one satisfying bite at a time.
Brother’s Roast Beef & Seafood
$ | (978) 538-7333 | WEBSITE
Brother’s Roast Beef & Seafood serves up generous portions of consistently tasty, flavorful, and fresh food worth stopping by for. Like the pizza with plenty of toppings and that signature cheese pull, or the large and hot calzones that are a local favorite.
Open any time of the day, even in the early mornings, Brother’s gets pretty busy with folks grabbing a quick lunch of delectable subs, families ordering take-out for dinner, and neighborhood regulars who swing by for whatever special is on—like Monday nights with 50% off pizzas. The staff is always polite, attentive, and greeting customers with a smile, making it a welcoming and accommodating spot whether you’re in for a quick bite or planning a cozy night in with their prompt delivery.
Plum Tomatoes Brick Oven Pizza
$ | (978) 538-7586 | WEBSITE
Plum Tomatoes Brick Oven Pizza in Peabody embraces a straightforward, no-frills approach when it comes to pizza. We’re not sure why, but the pizza is pretty damn good. Get slices of classic cheese, ricotta and eggplant, and pepperoni topped with fresh basil. Or opt to try the signature brick oven pie: tangy tomato sauce smothered over a chewy crust with quality mozzarella, which may or may not momentarily transport you to pizza heaven.
The new owner is friendly, the crew remains steady, and while the crust quality has raised some eyebrows, the made-to-order pies and drink variety keep regulars coming back for more flavor explorations.
Marano’s Trattoria
$ | (978) 535-0411 | WEBSITE
Marano’s Trattoria in Peabody has something for everyone, like spinach and cheese calzones or pizza with that authentic sauce. The family-run spot serves chicken parmesan, arancini, meatballs, and those must-try garlic bread starters. Build your own pasta dish topped with fresh broccoli or savory meatballs, or grab an Italian sub to-go. You might need a nap afterward.
Frankie Slice
$ | (978) 982-1800 | WEBSITE
The Peabody pizzeria Frankie Slice serves, well, pizza, a pie from the Italian tradition made with dough, a base from simple ingredients, and cheese called mozzarella. Both make the pizza chewy, stretchy, and a little less heavy than other kinds of pizza. Go for toppings like sausage or the crispy cup pepperoni—although every slice tastes just as savory and satisfying—and watch the staff slide out every order.
Gallo Nero
$$ | (978) 531-9833 | WEBSITE
When a craving for authentic Italian comfort food hits and your own kitchen feels miles away, head to Gallo Nero. The Peabody restaurant serves a broad selection of Italian classics that consistently impress. Get something hearty and satisfying like the famous Mediterranean calzone, or completely commit to an unforgettable pasta experience with the penne alla vodka featuring chicken and bacon. Your taste buds will thank you.
Best Sandwich Company
$ | (978) 535-7000 | WEBSITE
The Best Sandwich Company in Peabody, a sandwich and pizza destination, serves everything you need for a satisfying Italian sub-fueled meal of epic proportions. Want to pile everything on a seeded braided roll? No problem. Want a steak and cheese sub loaded with proportionate meat? Done. Best Sandwich Company makes any sandwich or pizza craving, possible. If you want to avoid the lunch rush clamoring for their unreal salt and vinegar fries, we suggest going during off-peak hours.
Giovanni’s Pizza & Roast Beef
$ | (978) 535-0293 | WEBSITE
Grabbing a roast beef sandwich from the Peabody staple Giovanni’s Pizza & Roast Beef feels like treating yourself to a home-cooked meal without any of the effort. Hearty, satisfying, and downright essential. The family-run spot serves some of the best classic roast beef in Massachusetts. While the menu offers plenty of variety, if you ever order the chicken parm, it’s an absolute must.
Santarpio’s Pizza
$ | (978) 535-1811 | WEBSITE
Santarpio’s Pizza really loves its hearty, generous approach. Not only is the inside of this long-standing pizza joint in Peabody mostly comfortable and welcoming, you can also order fresh and juicy pizza that’s so heavy it’s better eaten with a fork and knife. It also serves grilled meats and bread, with cherry peppers adding extra flavor to the menu.
If you can’t decide between pizza and barbecue, Santarpio’s allows you to enjoy both, so you can try their signature offerings without having to choose just one.