Despite what you told yourself last week, you’re nowhere near mastering the perfect homemade pizza crust. Fortunately, Sioux Falls is brimming with pizzerias offering incredible pies for your next game night, family dinner, or really, anytime you crave that perfect slice. Here are some places to savor cheesy, saucy, doughy perfection.
Fiero Pizza
$ | (605) 338-0505 | WEBSITE
Another reliable Sioux Falls pizzeria, Fiero Pizza serves satisfying personal-sized pies from their clean, casual space. We highly recommend the inventive chorizo and feta pizza, a flavorful combination that’s going to delight you with every chewy-crisp bite. On the simpler side, their classic pepperoni with that tangy red sauce is a solid choice we’ll happily order for a quick lunch. They’ve also perfected their cilantro ranch dipping sauce that pairs wonderfully with the crust.
Order via their website for speedy take-out, or $4 delivery within the local area.
Marco’s Pizza
$ | (605) 275-4949 | WEBSITE
Sioux Falls favorite Marco’s Pizza continues to deliver excellent pies during busy times, and that hasn’t changed with the recent sports season rush. In addition to standout specialties like the Hot Honey Magnifico and Philly cheese steak pizza, they’ve also got other great options, like their popular thin-crust pies and tasty pizza bowls. Also note that they’ve got a coupon system, with regularly discounted prices making it more affordable.
Available for quick takeout, prompt delivery for large groups, or enjoying their friendly atmosphere in-house.
Godfather’s Pizza
$ | (605) 361-8029 | WEBSITE
Your friends in bigger cities might find Godfather’s at their local strip mall. But just because it’s a familiar chain, doesn’t mean you’re not still getting excellent quality pizza from this Sioux Falls location. And because of their experience, this kitchen can deliver consistently, with perfectly cooked pies that arrive exactly when promised – like the Classic Combo with extra cheese, or the Taco pizza loaded with toppings.
If you’re not looking to experiment, get the dependable cheese pizza for something more traditional. Stop by for dine-in or order online for pick-up.
Pizza Cheeks
$ | (605) 271-0974 | WEBSITE
Pizza Cheeks is a tucked-away gem in Sioux Falls that specializes in authentic New York-style thin crust pizza. Our go-tos include the classic cheese slice, with its perfectly crisp crust and tangy sauce, and the Sweet Meat pizza drizzled with their signature Hot Honey sauce—a spicy-sweet combo that’s absolutely addictive. They’ve also got crowd-pleasers like meatball sliders and shareable desserts.
Grab a whole pie for dine-in (starting around $18 for a large) or swing by the back counter at Hello Hi on Phillips for a quick slice to go. Call (605) 123-4567 to check daily specials or reserve a table near the arcade games.
Charlie’s Pizza – Sioux Falls
$ | (605) 275-2212 | WEBSITE
Though Charlie’s Pizza is tucked away in Sioux Falls, you don’t even have to leave your car to enjoy their fantastic pies – they offer a smooth pick-up experience that’s become a local favorite. They often sell out of popular items during peak hours, but recent standouts have been the “Betty White” vegetarian pizza, and the “Festus” – a bold creation with pepper jack meatballs, jalapeños, and sauerkraut that’s spicy, tangy, and surprisingly delicious in the best way.
The visible kitchen adds to the clean, open atmosphere where you can watch the dough being stretched fresh. Dine-in for family pizza nights with large pies and pitchers of pop at affordable prices, or take it home to enjoy.
Little Caesars Pizza
$ | (605) 332-3131 | WEBSITE
If you haven’t tried the Minnesota Ave location yet, that’s about to change. This Sioux Falls spot delivers some of the fastest and most satisfying pizza around. Our go-to orders are the classic pepperoni pizza, always hot and delicious, and the new stuffed breadsticks that customers can’t stop raving about. They don’t usually get fancy with their menu, but during busy evenings, they’ve got everything ready to go – check their hours online for updates, and grab whatever looks good.
The manager here handled a difficult situation with grace recently, showing professionalism and generosity by offering Little Caesars cookies to a tired, hungry child. They also have another location on 10th Street, though that one doesn’t quite measure up to this gem.
Brix Wine Bar
$$ | (605) 212-1192 | WEBSITE
Just because you can find Brix Wine Bar in a list of pizza spots, doesn’t mean it’s not one of the best wine destinations in Sioux Falls. Their cozy location offers a thoughtfully curated wine list from around the world, featuring excellent selections like their manager’s picks and the Director of Wine’s recommendations, as well as their limited-availability bottles. Keep an eye out whenever they have their wood-fired pizzas, like the classic Margherita or the seasonal specials.
Also, any of their small plates, like the Figura e Burrata Crostini, are highly worth your time. Cozy atmosphere, top-tier service, and a warm, inviting vibe – check their website for reservations and hours.
The Lie’brary
$ | (605) 271-4451 | WEBSITE
The Lie’brary is a standout sports bar in Sioux Falls that opened just before the big game season kicked off. But they’ve adapted seamlessly, and have a fantastic selection of local brews available on tap—like Fernson Brewing Company right here in Sioux Falls, and the excellent Wooden Legs Brewing from nearby Brookings. They’ve also got excellent bar classics, if you’re craving some loaded nachos or a juicy burger to go with your pint. Stop by for the full experience.
Invictus Pizza Kitchen
$ | (605) 274-7492 | WEBSITE
Invictus Pizza Kitchen, a Sioux Falls favorite, has got seriously good pizza and a welcoming atmosphere. Their fresh ingredients (like the perfectly balanced cheese and sauce) are great, and we also love their patient and attentive service, which makes for a pleasant experience. In-store dining and takeout available at their location, along with options for those with food sensitivities.
B&G Milkyway Cliff
$ | (605) 271-1527 | WEBSITE
One of the best ice cream spots in Sioux Falls, B&G Milkyway Cliff has kept the quality going through the seasons, offering new treats like the California Dreaming, a refreshing, creamy blend, Choc/Vanilla Twist, a rich and smooth combination, and the Avalanche, a heavenly mix of ice cream with favorites like cookie dough and peanut butter cups.
Order at their drive-thru for a unique experience with employees delivering directly to your car, or enjoy the vibrant outdoor seating with fun music and family-friendly atmosphere.
Dareo’s Pizza Casino
$ | (605) 335-3758 | WEBSITE
Sioux Falls’ best spot for hard-to-find breakfast, Dareo’s Pizza Casino has a constantly satisfying selection of morning classics, everything from the spiritual cheese omelet and crispy-yet-soft hash browns to the sizzling chicken fried steak. Order from their fantastic and friendly staff who cater well to dietary restrictions like gluten allergies, or try your luck at the video lottery games for entertainment. There’s a hidden gem doing the same thing in town, too.
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
$ | (605) 362-4664 | WEBSITE
A staple in Sioux Falls since its arrival, Papa Murphy’s has been serving up take ‘n’ bake pizza for years. They’ve got a solid lineup of stock pizzas or build-your-own options, but our go-to (especially when we’re in a hurry) is the Murphy’s Combo – a classic pepperoni-and-sausage pie. The Create Your Own is also reliable. Open daily for pickup orders, or order ahead through their app.
Papa Johns Pizza
$ | (605) 361-7272 | WEBSITE
Papa Johns might be the most consistently reliable pizza delivery in Sioux Falls. And without those wait times, we like this spot even more. They’ve got excellent service every time, like Shawana’s attention to detail, or the prompt issue resolution that comes with any order. We recommend you try their signature crust – it usually satisfies within just a few bites.
Sunny’s Pizzeria
$ | (605) 271-4770 | WEBSITE
You probably know Sunny’s Pizzeria as one of the best – and occasionally, busiest – pizza joints in the city. But on a Friday night, they’re operating at full capacity, a cozy college spot featuring thin-crust pies, gluten-free options, and innovative combinations. The menu changes with creative specials, but recent standout toppings have included daring flavor pairings, classic favorites, and other great pizza creations.
The limited seating fills up fast, but the friendly staff keeps things moving with top-tier service while you enjoy the rad vibe with Sega games. Parking can be tight, but it’s usually manageable for this family-friendly destination.
Tomacelli’s Pizza & Pasta
$ | (605) 335-8500 | WEBSITE
Tomacelli’s Pizza & Pasta is serving up gourmet pies from their family-owned spot in Sioux Falls. The Spartichoke is a standout with its unique flavor profile, and the BBQ Hawaiian delivers that perfect sweet-and-savory combination. You should also try the gluten-free crust, which has such great texture and taste that even non-gluten-free diners rave about it. Order from their website for delivery with minimal fees.
Maribella Ristorante
$$ | (605) 271-1710 | WEBSITE
Maribella Ristorante isn’t a traditional pizzeria, but it’s still one of the best places to get authentic pizza in Sioux Falls. You’ll find all the classic Italian dishes like the 4 Seasons Pizza, phenomenal Risotto, and gluten-free pasta made fresh daily, and plenty of great options beyond pizza, too. It’s also one of the only places where you’ll find exceptional desserts like the vanilla Gelato with espresso poured over the top.
Dine in their beautiful, well-laid-out facility – you can enjoy the relaxed environment, or else trust their outstanding chefs, and let them impress you with their food presentation.
Pizza Ranch
$ | (605) 271-8646 | WEBSITE
Pizza Ranch is another large-scale pizza spot that still turns out great food. We love their buffet options, like the much-better-than-expected pizza and the good salad bar. Order on their website for $12 local delivery or dine-in pickup. Delivery available throughout Sioux Falls.
Roots of Brasil
$$ | (605) 271-1498 | WEBSITE
You can find Brazilian-inspired dishes at various spots around town, but you’ll need to visit Roots of Brasil in Sioux Falls to experience the full depth of authentic Brazilian cuisine. They’ve got an impressive selection of traditional offerings, from their feijoada (one of the most flavorful stews you’ll find, hands down), to all kinds of churrasco specialties, moqueca, and bacalhau, all of which are perfect for a cozy winter meal.
The Caribbean Jerked Chicken and Coconut Cristy Pork Risotto are particularly outstanding. Order takeout through their website, or delivery available via apps.