If you’re exploring St. Catharines, you’re likely here for the vibrant arts scene, the historic Welland Canal, or Niagara’s famous vineyards. But between gallery visits and wine tastings, you should also make time to discover the city’s surprisingly robust pizza culture—where wood-fired ovens and creative toppings transform this humble dish into something truly memorable.
The Pizza Company
$ | (905) 682-9211 | WEBSITE
Not to be confused with other pizza chains in the area, The Pizza Company is a straightforward spot that’s made pizza its entire focus. They’re most famous for their delicious pies that offer great value, but you shouldn’t ignore their consistent dining experience with friendly service. It costs about $3 extra to get your pizza with extra cheese, but some customers have expressed disappointment with the inability to customize the amount.
NGA2 steakhouse and grill
There isn’t much fine dining in St. Catharines, and NGA2 is one of the few spots in town that feels truly special. It’s elegant in the best way, with hearty tomahawk steaks, incredible salmon dishes, and servers like Chef David who will personally check on your table to ensure dietary needs are met.
The atmosphere is warm and family-friendly, with a quiet, clean setting where you can easily spend an evening savoring outstanding mussels or octopus while plotting which part of the menu you want to explore next.
Pie Guys Pizzeria
$$ | (289) 362-2221 | WEBSITE
This straightforward pizzeria on the city’s pizza scene is the best place in town to grab a solid pie. You can get really analytical trying to compare crust textures and sauce-to-cheese ratios across their different offerings, or you can just go all-in on a few slices of their delicious Mexican pizza and have fun with their amazing Thursday wing special. The friendly staff keeps things moving smoothly, making it worth every penny for a reliable pizza night with friends.
Rollin’ Pizza – Handcrafted Pizza + Pasta
$ | (905) 938-9797 | WEBSITE
Many pizza joints in St. Catharines feel generic, but not Rollin’ Pizza. That’s exactly why their cozy spot should be your go-to for satisfying slices and comforting pasta after a long day. Recharge by grabbing a BBQ Chicken pizza loaded with generous toppings and a perfectly crisp crust at one of their small dining tables. Or, settle into the warm atmosphere with some Butter Chicken pizza featuring rich, flavorful sauce and balanced toppings that hit all the right notes.
Pie Guys Tap And Grill
$$ | (289) 362-2221 | WEBSITE
Pie Guys Tap and Grill might not have a fancy patio, but its cozy dining room still feels like a welcoming neighborhood hangout complete with warm lighting and sports memorabilia on the walls. It’s easy to spend an entire evening sharing generous pizzas and plump wings while sipping cold beers and chatting with the friendly staff—they’ll even bring you extra napkins if you need them after diving into the double pepperoni pizza.
Make sure to order the wings sauced just right and topped with that perfect homemade dough crust.
Red Swan Pizza
$ | (905) 646-3555 | WEBSITE
Red Swan Pizza’s generous-topped pies are a welcome alternative to all the heavy pasta dishes in St. Catharines. The sesame seed-crusted dough with its crispy-yet-soft texture is perfect when you need a quick, satisfying meal after running errands, and the Paneer Pizza with its smoky Ancho Chipotle base should be your go-to choice for flavorful vegetarian options.
Industria Pizzeria + Bar
$$ | (289) 273-9117 | WEBSITE
If it’s a glorious day out, you should get at least one meal to go and eat it in the great outdoors (or at least on some grass). Industria Pizzeria + Bar does takeout, so grab a giant pizza with seasonal toppings and put it into your hiking backpack to share on a trail or at the top of a postcard-like vista.
Pizzas are piled high with incredible ingredients—we love the delicious pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom situation—and they also have tasty calamari that can serve as a perfect snack when you forget to pack appetizers for a sports-watching party.
Fat Cat’s Pizza Inc.
$ | (905) 685-1585 | WEBSITE
This pizza spot sits a bit further from St. Catharines’ bustling downtown core, but its location in a friendly neighborhood makes it a perfect family dinner destination or casual weekend treat. It can get quite busy during Friday and Saturday evenings, but it’s absolutely worth the wait for their spicy “ninth life” wings and generous pasta dishes.
The Cajun Alfredo pasta is rich and beautifully creamy in each forkful, and other options like the Chef Salad and jalapeño dumplings will keep the pizza-purists happy too. The “Big Slice” deal with a medium pizza slice and drink offers fantastic value, and the overall atmosphere feels warm and welcoming with staff who genuinely seem to enjoy what they do.
Westside Pizzeria/Bar
$ | (905) 682-4444 | WEBSITE
St. Catharines isn’t exactly a fine dining destination, so Westside Pizzeria/Bar stands out as a place where you can impress somebody who deeply cares about massive portions and casual celebrations. But despite serving $20 pizzas and having a menu board the size of a pool table, it’s not overly basic. Even though they’re delicious, don’t fill up on smaller plates like tasty pierogi panzarotti and great wings in various heat levels.
Save room for the giant order of nachos with plenty of toppings and a pizza that glistens like a game-day feast ready for sharing.
Coppola’s Ristorante & Banquet Facility
$$ | (905) 688-6694 | WEBSITE
There are unfortunately no gondolas at this Italian spot on St. Catharines’ main drag, but you should still end your evening here by digging into homemade pasta and a flaky fig flatbread topped with creamy mozzarella. The banquet space also makes for some good celebration-watching as special occasion guests prepare to toast engagement parties or host baby showers.