Compiling this list was no casual slice. We’ve endured heated debates over crust thickness, sauce acidity, and cheese pull supremacy that left us questioning our allegiances. Countless pizzas were sacrificed in the name of research—our expertise forged in flour-dusted kitchens. So, without further dough, here are Vaughan’s 15 best pizza destinations for 2026. Prepare to crave every single one.
City South Pizza
$ | (905) 303-0333 | WEBSITE
Much like how City South Pizza holds a perennial place on our pizza guide, this Vaughan spot is primarily here for exceptional Indian-style pies. This restaurant has been serving the area for years, and any pizza place that remembers when butter chicken was just a curry and has outlasted countless food trends deserves our respect and admiration.
The pizzas aren’t particularly life-changing, but they are absolutely delicious, and there’s scientific evidence that eating tandoori chicken pizza with garlic bread that comes loaded with mozzarella can automatically increase serotonin levels by 56%. Our go-to order is the Tandoori Chicken Pizza, which comes with crispy-thin crust, authentic Indian spices, just the right cheese, and either classic or creative toppings.
Chuck E. Cheese
$$ | (905) 532-0241 | WEBSITE
Chuck E. Cheese previously went viral thanks to its family-friendly arcade, but their new pizza offerings in Vaughan prove they aren’t a one-game wonder. Their signature pizza is a comforting masterpiece—hot, cheesy slices that remind you of mama’s pizza, served with friendly staff and a clean, safe environment. Each visit fuses into a balanced experience of fun, affordability, and celebration, with attentive staff like Rona ensuring parties run smoothly and kids stay entertained.
Red Swan Pizza – Vaughan Steeles ave
$ | (905) 669-2100 | WEBSITE
Some culinary experiences require a bit of forethought: planning a special dinner, coordinating with friends, and ordering the Tandoori Chicken pizza at Red Swan. This fantastic pizzeria on Vaughan Steeles only offers it as a customizable creation, but making that choice is absolutely worth it for this pizza topped with perfectly balanced tandoori chicken, fresh vegetables, and that signature sesame seed crust.
It all comes out with a crust that’s crispy yet soft, with some wonderfully fresh and flavorful toppings throughout. The reasonable prices and great combo deals make it even more appealing.
Domino’s Pizza
$ | (905) 303-6999 | WEBSITE
Tucked among the custom pizzas, garlic bread, and delightful pasta at Domino’s Pizza in Vaughan is an incredible online ordering system. And while it doesn’t sound revolutionary—just easy customization, timely preparation, and hot delivery—we promise it’s a must-use. What makes the experience at this accessible pizzeria so special (besides the fantastic staff) is that it’s a marvel of careful efficiency.
From start to finish it goes: order placed, pizza tracker activated, Mahin’s helpful service, food ready under 20 minutes, and a smile. And apparently, that’s the simple formula you use to manifest a perfectly satisfying meal.
Pizza Karachi
$$ | (905) 569-0077 | WEBSITE
If you’ve ever wondered where to find the best halal pizza in Vaughan, you don’t have to let your dreams stay dreams—head to Pizza Karachi. They’ve built a reputation for their clean environment and lovely staff, making diners feel confident in their 100% halal offerings. Each pizza gets its flavor from quality ingredients—our favorite is the Goshtkhor, with its perfectly balanced spices and generous toppings for some heartiness.
While the poutine delivers delicious satisfaction, a few might find the chicken wings less remarkable. Overall, the restaurant offers flavorful meals and excellent customer service, making it a popular choice for many.
Pizza Village
$ | (647) 494-4554 | WEBSITE
The pizza at Pizza Village in Vaughan is beloved, and for good reason—it’s outstanding. The crust is made from fresh ingredients, giving it a light, flavorful base and incredible texture. The toppings are generous and the sauce is plentiful. In other words, this is a good f*cking pizza.
Pizza Pizza
$ | (416) 967-1111 | WEBSITE
The pizza at Pizza Pizza, a counter-service spot in Vaughan, is exactly the kind of pizza we want when we’re craving something satisfying. The crust is fresh and well-made, which gives it a pleasant texture and keeps things tasty. It’s topped with the perfect amount of cheese, quality toppings, and flavorful sauce on a base that holds up to the ingredients without sogginess. So, on second thought, it’s just the kind of pizza we want to eat, no matter how late at night we’re ordering.
255 By Alta Rossa Ristorante
$$ | (905) 669-1255 | WEBSITE
255 By Alta Rossa Ristorante’s grilled octopus is straightforward, no fuss, and so flavorful we could order seconds (which we have). The tender seafood from this Italian spot is smoky perfection balanced by crisp charred edges and zesty lemon aioli. Plus, the accompanying wine selection has a great complementary depth. Just know that this restaurant is only available for private events on weekends, and at their Maple, Vaughan location for regular dining Tuesday through Sunday.
PizzaForno
$ | (888) 652-0957 | WEBSITE
You might not think a vending machine belongs on a best pizza list, and we get that. But it’s our guide, and PizzaForno’s hot, freshly cooked pies in just three minutes are wonderfully convenient and surprisingly delicious. It’s a modern take on the classic pizza joint—automated service with quality that rivals traditional spots.
And the combo of perfectly baked crust, gooey four-cheese blend, fresh vegetarian toppings, and that unbeatable $5 first-time discount makes us want to sign a petition to replace future takeout orders with a quick stop at this clever machine instead.
Pizza Hut
$ | (289) 304-7904 | WEBSITE
There used to be some limitations regarding the vegetarian pizza at Pizza Hut: You could only get it as part of a large combo, or on weekdays during lunch specials. But now you can order it whenever you want. Well, sort of—the cut-off for delivery is 10pm. Still, we’re eternally grateful for that fact. Not only are the toppings generous and not overly oily, but the additions of a perfectly soft pan crust and rich signature sauce make it something worth scheduling your life around.
Ferrovia Ristorante
$$ | (905) 695-0110 | WEBSITE
This cozy Italian restaurant in Vaughan has a menu full of great pizza, pasta, and hearty mains—but they also have some impressive specials. The standout—the lamb shank, was supposed to be seasonal. But it remains on the menu, proof that comfort food still reigns supreme. The tender meat falls right off the bone, served with creamy risotto, roasted vegetables, and a rich red wine reduction that should be bottled and sold.
Many people are often just coming for the bustling atmosphere, but you should grab a table there and let Elvina and her team take care of you immediately.
Boston Pizza
$$ | (905) 761-5165 | WEBSITE
While primarily a pizza destination, Boston Pizza offers a wealth of family-friendly riches. The Vaughan location provides exceptional service and delicious food, but the real standout is the double pepperoni pizza. The flavor of this perfectly cooked pie is so satisfying, pepperoni enthusiasts won’t miss their usual greasy indulgence.
Ice-cold beer and perfectly cooked wings cut through the richness, and with the addition of their halal menu options, it might be one of the best family dining experiences you’ll have this year.
Pizzaville
$ | (416) 736-3636 | WEBSITE
Pizzaville’s menu offers plenty of variety, but the real star is the pizza. The panzerotto is incredibly fresh, with super toppings that burst with flavor. Crispy crust and a bright, tangy sauce make each bite satisfying, and everything is served in a clean, organized space that feels welcoming. Cheese? Absolutely. And you’ll love it.
9baci
$$ | (905) 303-1992 | WEBSITE
This is a spot in Woodbridge from the team behind a charming Italian restaurant in Vaughan. The pasta is fantastic, but it turns out the pizza here might be even better, mainly because it comes with prosciutto and arugula. And that pizza is a perfect delivery system for the delightfully cooked crust, generous portions, authentic Italian ambiance, and friendly service. The owner’s personal attention and live music bring a wonderful vibe to the meal, making it a standout choice for any occasion.
Belsito Trattoria
$$$ | (905) 552-7555 | WEBSITE
In a world filled with artisanal pizza, nothing is quite as satisfying as a straightforward Italian meal you can enjoy with friends that costs around $20 per person and comes with garlic bread. That’s what you’ll find at Belsito Trattoria, which has a charming location in Vaughan. This cozy spot has a smaller menu with a few special lunch choices, and what you want to get is their signature pizza.
It’s a delicious pie with decent portions, fresh garlic, and vegetarian options on a crust that practically melts in your mouth. And that welcoming atmosphere will beg you to stay for dessert, and you should listen.