Let’s be honest: when you’re craving a memorable meal in Bunnell, you want more than just sustenance—you want an experience. Too often, ‘best’ lists lead to overhyped spots with lackluster plates. But not here. These ten restaurants deliver both atmosphere and exceptional flavor, proving that in this charming Florida town, you can indeed have it all.
Becca’s Sweet Tooth
Is it possible to out-sweet Becca’s Sweet Tooth? Possibly, but only by its own wedding cakes. There’s even a Sausage and Cheddar Quiche paired with Caribou coffee for breakfast – simple, yet satisfying.
Terranova’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
$ | (386) 437-3101 | WEBSITE
How do you get us to eat at a family-owned pizzeria in Bunnell without wanting to kick our own *ss? By serving amazing crust and custom-made vegetarian options in a cozy version of a classic Italian eatery.
Bantam Chef
$ | (386) 437-3804 | WEBSITE
Bantam Chef is basically the roadside restaurant version of a hidden gem, and most of the people are packed into the small takeout counter that serves incredible fish sandwiches. There’s also a picnic bench seating area outside, and a more functional kitchen space in the back. You should look like you’re hitting the beach after your meal, even if deep-down you know you’re heading straight for a food coma.
Knuckle Sandwich Sub Shop
$ | (386) 263-8232 | WEBSITE
Knuckle Sandwich Sub Shop is such a local gem it honestly surprises us on a busy weekday. Particularly because the food is impressive and everything from the Bourbon sandwich to the triple are great.
Giuseppe’s NY Pizza & Pasta Express
$ | (386) 586-3535 | WEBSITE
A local favorite in Bunnell, Giuseppe’s NY Pizza & Pasta Express delivers classic Italian comfort with genuine neighborhood charm. In other words, expect thin-crust pizza that brings back childhood memories. It’s a welcoming spot, with really outstanding food.
Los Dos Potrillos Mexican Restaurant
$ | (386) 437-4078 | WEBSITE
Los Dos Potrillos is everything we like about authentic Mexican dining combined with everything we like about a hidden gem. That means great food and service in an old-school space. Everyone knows the key to being authentic is not trying too hard to be authentic, and Los Dos Potrillos does exactly that.
E & S Foods Inc
$ | (386) 586-2925 | WEBSITE
We’ve walked past plenty of fancy butcher shops before. No way you’re going to catch us paying boutique prices for a simple sandwich when we can get generous portions and quality meats at E & S Foods. But we have no problem being judged by the regulars if it means enjoying one of their bone-in ribeyes or a fresh deli sandwich. The family-owned spot offers friendly, fast service and fair prices that keep loyal customers coming back year after year.
While the facility could use an upgrade and a printed menu would help, the consistency and personal touch make it worth overlooking those details. Just be prepared for bread that’s on the firmer side—some customers prefer it softer, but it holds up well to their substantial fillings.
Melina’s Empanadas
$ | (386) 263-8340 | WEBSITE
Melina’s Empanadas is the type of take on classic Puerto Rican street food that only a true hidden gem could pull off. It’s fresh, crunchy, and consistently serves amazing empanadas. Of course, a spot that isn’t so fancy will be the kind of place people who love fried delights hang out, but it’s good enough to keep us continuously coming back for more.
Crossroads Tavern
$ | (386) 313-1444 | WEBSITE
You can try and dismiss Crossroads Tavern all you want because it’s just a neighborhood bar and everyone there seems friendlier than you, but look: the experience is genuine. From the lively karaoke nights to the welcoming bartenders and fun bar bingo, we always have a good time here.
The Southern Table
$ | (386) 263-3120 | WEBSITE
There are a few places to get good Southern food in town, but The Southern Table stands alone as both a friendly and casual place to do it. Don’t forget to order the country fried steak and key lime pie for a satisfying meal.