There’s something about strolling St. Augustine’s cobblestone streets, the scent of salt air mingling with sizzling garlic, that whispers Florida history with every hungry step. These days your options go way beyond tourist-trap seafood. Here are the best places to dine in the nation’s oldest city, from waterfront fine dining to Minorcan chowder joints where the datil pepper heat lingers like a Spanish ghost.
Bar None Saloon
$ | (904) 825-4202 | WEBSITE
This little dive bar in St. Augustine’s historic district specializes in friendly service and good drinks. It’s all very welcoming—think Nick serenading guests with his guitar and Emily bringing water bowls for visiting dogs. But this place feels as genuine as it sounds. We love Bar None’s laid-back vibe when Nick is on duty, but Emily’s awesome service and pretty smile are a very close second.
Cinco De Mayo
$ | (904) 484-7162 | WEBSITE
Cinco De Mayo makes some seriously good Mexican food. Menu-wise, you can expect everything from chorizo fundido and tacos to burritos and fajita quesadillas, plus several homemade hot sauce options. Their original location is in St. Augustine but the Cinco De Mayo spot has the advantage of a lively atmosphere, which is perfect if you’re looking for more of a celebratory situation. Or if you want to enjoy delicious margaritas with fresh and tasty food, because Florida.
Back 40 Urban Cafe
$ | (904) 824-0227 | WEBSITE
This charming spot in the heart of St. Augustine has been serving its bold flavors and warm atmosphere for years. Our favourite order is the dynamite shrimp tacos with a side of their sublime soup. But you can get plenty of delicious grouper tacos, juicy burgers, and some top-quality coffee from the delightful staff. The cozy decor features local artwork, creating a haven where joy calls. Must-try desserts include the heavenly key lime pie and decadent mud pie.
With its fresh, bright, and flavorful dishes, Back 40 Urban Cafe stands out as a gem that keeps customers coming back for more.
Mayita
$ | (904) 429-9205 | WEBSITE
Mayita is a loveable restaurant that draws you in with a crooning Spanish soundtrack and tacos that are more like feasts. This is a beloved St. Augustine spot and locals know the staff well, but even if you’re new to these parts, friendly servers will offer as many recommendations as you like without batting an eyelid and never hurry you out of the roomy waterfront tables.
Our go-to order is the al pastor tacos—sometimes they’re served with extra homemade hot sauce, and that’s best—with a side of delightful guacamole.
The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe
$ | (904) 342-5447 | WEBSITE
While we’re usually drawn to the classic holiday drinks from the coffee shop down the street, The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe’s vegan options challenge our routine. The wonderfully smooth signature oat milk latte is like that perfect froth on top of a cappuccino, and then some. Pair it with one of their rotating desserts: a rich chocolate mousse paired with a vegan soft serve for a holiday-inspired treat has been a recent favorite.
Tony’s Pizza New York Style
$ | (904) 471-9027 | WEBSITE
Tony’s Pizza New York Style is busy all day long. The pizzas range from a savory white pizza with chicken and onions, to a loaded supreme pizza that’ll satisfy even the heartiest appetite. Of the options, the white pizza is our go-to and a slice of supreme alongside it adds a nice variety. Grab a spot across the street at the park for excellent outdoor dining, or head inside the cozy, family-friendly spot with limited seating.
Smoked. Southern BBQ
$ | (904) 824-8222 | WEBSITE
It’s your classic barbecue tale. Smoke meets meat. That’s what Southern comfort is all about, right? This solid BBQ spot in St. Augustine serves some wonderfully generous portions. There are plenty of excellent options, like the popular beef brisket, which is a must-try. Plus, the smoked ribs are some of the best we’ve tried, falling right off the bone. Don’t miss the tasty snacks like corn nuggets that you can enjoy while watching the roaming peacocks.
Les Petits Pleasures
$ | (904) 679-3411 | WEBSITE
There are many French bakeries in St. Augustine but our favourite is Les Petits Pleasures—it’s open daily, with a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit special. The almond croissant is the pastry we want to start every day with. But they also do an amazing chocolate Merveilleux too—pastries are baked fresh daily, with delicate buttery flavors and many flaky layers.
They’ve got great options, like the veggie omelette on croissant, and exceptional service with staff meticulously describing every item in the case.
Hazel’s Hot Dogs
$ | (904) 315-6546 | WEBSITE
It’s a truth universally acknowledged that anything served with hand-cut fries becomes instantly more satisfying. And the hot dogs at this St. Augustine spot—the classic snappy dog, the spicy bestseller, and the Datil dog from the dessert menu, all of which can be topped with cheese or chili—demonstrate that principle perfectly. Hazel’s also offers their shakes in chocolate if you’re more into a classic milkshake situation.
Smokin’ D’s BBQ
$ | (904) 797-2050 | WEBSITE
Smokin’ D’s BBQ is best-known as a genuine Southern BBQ joint in St. Augustine. But during any season, alongside its perfectly smoked, juicy meats like the highly recommended smoked turkey and fall-off-the-bone ribs, you’ll find excellent sides like the beans and great sauces. Get a beach bucket for a light lunch and enjoy the rustic, yet pleasant dining area. Many visitors appreciate the convenient location and great atmosphere, often returning for more delicious BBQ.
Simone’s Wood Fired Craft Kitchen
$$ | (904) 875-2317 | WEBSITE
This gem along the historic streets has a warm, inviting feel. Expect flavors like wood-fired Margherita pizza, as well as caprese salads and tempting desserts to choose from. We’re big fans of the bread pudding alongside other favorites, but it’s also worth trying their daily specials. Previous ones have included incredible lasagna that never disappoints.
With attentive service from staff like Hunter and perfect drink refills, it’s a slice of heaven worth the wait—typically shorter than expected—whether you sit inside or out. The great selection of wine and beer makes it ideal for date night or a casual meal, leaving you wanting to come back for more of those homemade flavors.
Creative Juices Natural Cafe
$ | (904) 342-0935 | WEBSITE
Creative Juices Natural Cafe is a natural foods spot on St. Augustine’s most welcoming stretch. The menu is split into ‘everyday’ and ‘adventurous’, think rye toast and root vege medley on one side and açai bowls with unexpected toppings on the other. The options are plentiful, so trust this: everything is satisfying. If you need a nudge, the tofu scramble with fresh herbs and perfect seasoning is a standout, so are the gluten-free pancakes which made us murmur, ‘that is pure, straight comfort’.
The simplest recipes yield the most incredible taste. The highest praise we can offer.
Pirate Pizza WGV
$ | (904) 615-1358 | WEBSITE
This cozy pizza joint in St. Augustine has a 30.00 special that’s so generous we wouldn’t be surprised if it was designed to feed a whole pirate crew. Every pizza and salad comes with that consistently good sauce and crust that keeps customers coming back.
Stop by for a satisfying meal and just know that once you get a taste of their delicious offerings—the incredible Davy Jones Italian sub, the popular steak and cheese sandwich, those meatball and mushroom toppings—you’ll be finding excuses to return, even if you’re not staying nearby.
Gringos Tacos
$ | (904) 217-0176 | WEBSITE
This vibrant taco joint serves up delicious tacos, burritos, and queso with chips, and everything from their flavorful organic chicken taco, to the popular vegan meat options makes this spot stand out. The birria tacos are a highlight, though some find the sauce a bit watery. Do try something a little different, like the street-style tacos, as well though. The eclectic decor adds to the fun atmosphere, and the friendly staff make for a great dining experience with quick service.
With vegetarian options for all entrees and reasonable prices around $8-12 per plate, Gringos Tacos continues to be a welcoming spot for various dietary preferences.