Head to the rolling hills of northwest New Jersey and you’ll discover Mount Olive. This charming township is known for its scenic landscapes and vibrant community, and is also dotted with exceptional eateries—you’ll find everything from farm-to-table bistros to cozy Italian trattorias and authentic global cuisine.
Mama’s Cafe Baci
$$ | (908) 852-2820 | WEBSITE
When you need a reliably excellent gluten-free meal in the area, Mama’s Cafe Baci is the obvious choice. The family-friendly restaurant in Hackettstown is a local favorite—they do have live music on Fridays though, so do all the necessary planning to experience it. We love the 4 Season Sampler Pizza, which is loaded with fresh toppings and just the right amount of flavor, along with their simple yet superb gluten-free chicken fingers and decadent Cinnabons.
Davila’s Pizza and Catering
$ | (908) 850-9500 | WEBSITE
Davila’s Pizza and Catering is a spot for simple, well-executed Italian-American food—and there are a lot of options, from classic Margherita pizza to chicken parm to Sicilian pizza. You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu at this casual place, but our favorites include the extra melty Margherita pizza with fresh basil that’s baked to perfection, the juicy chicken parm, and the garlic knots that you’ll want to order by the dozen.
The pasta fagioli soup flavors are consistent, but the not-too-heavy version is a winner.
Linda’s Gourmet Biscotti & Bakery
$ | (908) 246-2233 | WEBSITE
This biscotti bakery excels at the art of the gourmet treat. The matcha, chai tea, anise, and cranberry white chocolate ones at this charming Chester shop are crafted with melt-in-your-mouth texture, and run only $3 apiece (that’s no misprint). They’re also damn delightful, packed with fabulous flavors and available in gluten-free and non-dairy options. During special occasions, the line snakes through the racks of curated gift boxes and baked goods, and out the door.
But the service is personable and welcoming, and you’ll be with your loaded bakery bag and on your way in no time.
EFSANE MEDITERRANEAN cuisine
$$ | (862) 219-5340 | WEBSITE
Longtime fans of authentic Turkish dining in the Mount Olive area have a delicious destination to call their own: EFSANE MEDITERRANEAN cuisine, an excellent dinner and takeout spot with a welcoming ambiance. The full-service restaurant serves Mediterranean staples like perfectly seasoned lamb chops, generous mix grill platters, and falafel praised as the best around. Don’t miss the vegetarian okra dish or the comforting lentil soup with fresh, pillowy bread made in-house.
Get here for family gatherings or parties—it’s usually easy to park and enjoy attentive service in the warm, inviting dining room or take your feast to go.
Byram Bay Bistro
$$ | (973) 810-2061 | WEBSITE
Byram Bay Bistro is a restaurant that offers a unique Jamaican and Polish fusion cuisine. It’s a great spot for a fun dinner—everyone from the servers to the hosts is friendly and attentive, making guests feel at home. This spot serves fusion classics, like jerk seasoned lamb chops, panko crusted chicken cutlet, and potato pancakes, plus a few dishes inspired by Chef Mike. Just make sure to order the mushroom soup with its deep umami flavor and the pierogies with mango habanero sauce.
James on Main
$$$ | (908) 852-2131 | WEBSITE
Do you need a place that can host a special occasion and impress the discerning diners in your life? James on Main is your place. While it’s an elegant dining establishment located on a charming main street, the menu has sophistication, and something for everyone (even your friend with allergies)—like perfectly cooked mussels, fresh oysters, and a succulent Porterhouse.
The service is attentive, so it’s the ideal place for a memorable dinner or celebration (they also offer takeout, off-site BBQ events, and catering).
Cambiotti’s Tomato Pie Cafe
$ | (973) 770-1020 | WEBSITE
Cambiotti’s Tomato Pie Cafe serves the same excellent pizza as their original location, which is great news for anyone who loves their classic thin-crust pie with tangy-sweet sauce—like us. This cafe has a more intimate, small-town atmosphere than their other spots, so it’s better suited for a relaxed meal because you want to savor the experience and time feels abundant.
Fortunately that makes it easy to enjoy our favorites, like the standout tomato pie with its crispy crust and fresh mozzarella, and the chicken parm sandwich on garlic bread that’s hearty and satisfying.
New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant
$ | (908) 879-4424 | WEBSITE
You could (and should) come to New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant, a family-owned establishment in Mount Olive, and enjoy a classic New York-style pizza slice, a Greek salad, and other Italian staples. But don’t miss out on their menu of great sandwiches and entrees with authentic flavors. If you’re stuck on what to order, we recommend the famous cheesesteak, the veggie pizza with its crispy-yet-foldable crust, and the selection of salads and sandwiches.
This place is so welcoming that you’ll never have to worry about finding a friendly face like Allie’s or a warm atmosphere in the middle of your dining experience.
Sabor Latino Guatemalan (Netcong)
$ | (973) 527-7308 | WEBSITE
Sabor Latino Guatemalan is a Netcong Guatemalan restaurant we wish existed in every town. The cozy sit-down spot does a zesty, lime-kissed ceviche, complete with chips and perfectly fresh avocado. Stop by for lunch or dinner and settle into one of the comfortable booths inside, or if you’re grabbing takeout, enjoy your bowl of seafood at home with friends.
Shokudo ramen and sushi
$ | (908) 269-8390 | WEBSITE
This authentic Japanese gem has been serving the Mount Olive area for years, and they’re still dishing out their mouth-melting ramen and sushi from their cozy storefront. But their real magic happens in the kitchen where they prepare everything fresh daily (cash is accepted). The selection varies, but you can count on a mix of Salmon Sashimi, the Hackettstown Roll, Angry Dragon Roll, and Hollywood Roll.
As you’d expect from one of the town’s best Japanese spots, their ramen (especially the Shio Beef), never miss.
All Roads Baked Goods and Coffee
$ | (973) 885-4391 | WEBSITE
Looking for a perfect vegan treat? You need All Roads Baked Goods and Coffee. It’s a cozy morning spot to visit when the sun is bright and the air is crisp, since it’s just a charming bakery located in a welcoming space that’s full of beautiful plants and relaxing vibes. As far as the baked goods get one with delicious flavors like the avocado toast that complements the fresh ingredients.
While you’re here for the sweets, there’s also a selection of solid drinks, like the notable turmeric latte, and simple favorites like the banana chocolate chip muffin.
Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
$$ | (973) 691-1330 | WEBSITE
When you’re craving Italian comfort done right, the cozy dining room at this family-run spot beckons. It’s an elegant little haven in Long Valley, complete with warm lighting for intimate dinners and charming tables for groups. It’s also welcoming for takeout, thanks to quick preparation and reliable service. Wherever you enjoy it, just make sure the exceptional thin-crust grandma’s pizza, or the amazing pizza with soft cheese and thin crust are on your plate.
Also, for those with dietary needs, satisfying vegetarian options and a gluten-free menu are thoughtfully available.
Chili’s Grill & Bar
$ | (973) 691-8356 | WEBSITE
Chili’s Grill & Bar is a family-friendly restaurant and casual dining spot that’s perfect for quick lunches, relaxed dinners, or weekend gatherings. This welcoming place is a suburban staple: full of comfortable booths, warm lighting, and cheerful staff. Beyond their commitment to attentive service and clean environments, their menu of burgers, fajitas, ribs, and appetizers delivers satisfying takes on American comfort food.
Standout items include the baby back ribs glazed in signature barbecue sauce and the classic burger piled high with fresh toppings and melted cheese.
Burnt Mills Cider
$$ | (908) 781-6000 | WEBSITE
This cozy cider spot near Mount Olive delivers world-changing beach bonfire cider. It’s incredibly balanced, sweet and spicy all at once, and the explosion of flavors will have eyes popping out of your head like a cartoon. There are a few options (including lavender and cherry), from a refreshing and crisp lavender to tart cherry. While the ciders are why you’re here, don’t ignore the lobster mac and cheese from Angry Archie’s food truck. If it’s available, get the lobster mac and cheese.
Panera Bread
$$ | (973) 426-9200 | WEBSITE
Panera Bread is executing soup-and-salad sorcery. This café has pretty standard offerings, like generously portioned Pick 2 combos, vegetarian soups, and lunch salads big enough to satisfy a serious appetite. But this is comfort-food paradise, so you’re here for the soup, specifically in the form of a steaming bowl with bread on the side. The food is generally good, fresh, and will make you rethink everything you know about quick-casual dining.
There’s also a pleasant atmosphere for spending quality one-on-one time with friends, though you might find the prices a bit high for what you get.
Jersey Girl Brewing
$$ | (908) 591-4186 | WEBSITE
Jersey Girl Brewing is the perfect evening hangout: it involves delicious beers and a comfortable atmosphere, like the praised Elder Magic brew and Chuck’s expertly crafted ciders—they won’t leave you disappointed, and taste excellent, too. If available, go for the cozy indoor seating for socializing, or the simple yet inviting outdoor area for live music during warmer months.
This place is where to unwind and relax—it’s spacious with nice tables and full of good energy you’ll want to spend all evening with.