Brooklyn is awash in artisanal sandwich shops—places where a single pressed panini and housemade pickles might cost you $22. And then there are the stalwart delis that have been piling meat high for generations. Because sometimes, you just want to sink your teeth into an overstuffed hero, point to the perfect pickle from the barrel, and wash it down with a classic egg cream. At these essential spots, you’ll find exactly that.
Ba Xuyên
$ | (718) 633-6601 | WEBSITE
You can’t miss Ba Xuyên. The Brooklyn sandwich shop is painted in warm yellow and green tones, with simple wooden tables and stools that invite you to settle in. Come here when you want to grab a crusty banh mi and a taro shake while catching up with friends after a busy morning. While some snacks might be simple, you’ll be thrilled with the #6 Chicken Sandwich—fresh, light, and perfectly balanced.
You can try other options, but there are also popular picks like the authentic cold cut sandwich (#1) with lovely veggies and meat—we love it with a side of pandan cake and a Vietnamese coffee.
Mission Sandwich Social
$$ | (347) 529-5328 | WEBSITE
While most of Brooklyn’s classic delis cluster in Williamsburg, Mission Sandwich Social is an outlier in Bushwick. The neighborhood spot constantly plays indie rock and the staff shares stories about what the area was like back in the ’90s, all while you dig into huge sandwiches like the Four Horsemen and the Gobbler. Infinitely walk-in friendly, this is a good place to keep in mind when you need a laid-back lunch or quick dinner venue.
La sandwicherie Greenpoint
$ | (347) 987-4870 | WEBSITE
Classic, butter-rich sandwiches await at this charming Greenpoint shop. The space is split between a cozy counter area and a few small tables overlooking the quiet neighborhood street. Both are filled daily with locals, foodies, and regulars who have been coming here since it opened. Go for the generous portion of Le Parisien with melted Brie or the flaky croissants with authentic foie gras, and always close out with the sweet crêpes topped with fresh fruit for dessert.
Taku Sando
$ | (347) 294-0461 | WEBSITE
Taku Sando has been drawing in Brooklyn locals since it opened, even though it’s tucked away on a quiet side street. Inside this Japanese sandwich shop, there’s no music—just the sizzle of the fryer, chatter between neighboring tables, and sometimes the happy bark of a dog from the back patio (which you should definitely say hello to). The Ton-Katsu Sando and the Ribbon Fries are must-orders, but the friendly service is what makes a visit here special—it’s some of the best in the neighborhood.
Arrive right at noon, or be prepared to wait.
Court Street Grocers Williamsburg
$ | (833) 533-3200 | WEBSITE
Like most spots on this guide, a meal at Court Street Grocers Williamsburg is all about stacked sandwiches, a lot of flavorful sauces, and the possibility of gluten-free bread for an extra charge. The Williamsburg staple is a great place to bring relatives whose preferred sandwich size is a double-decker.
Pull up a seat alongside the regulars who have been coming here for quick bites, order the Ultimate Warrior loaded with tender pork shoulder and broccoli rabe, and shower it in an unreasonable amount of their super saucy options. The corned beef Reuben is perfect, and The Breakfast Sandwich with soft scrambled eggs, cheddar cheese, and arugula on ciabatta bread is simple yet filling. With friendly staff and plenty of vegan choices available, it’s a spot where every ingredient holds its own.
Brooklyn Hero Shop
$ | (718) 576-3958 | WEBSITE
There are plenty of reasons to visit this Clinton Hill gem. Since it opened, families have gathered at the sidewalk tables with strollers, dog owners have settled in for people-watching sessions, and friends can often be spotted sharing pickles and olives from the little Italian market. You’re definitely here for the atmosphere—sunny outdoor seating, neighborhood bustle, and welcoming accessibility included—rather than fancy dining.
But if you focus on the frickin’ eggplant sandwich or the Cold Italian that’s more flavor than bread, you’ll have a spectacular time.
Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe
$ | (718) 383-7395 | WEBSITE
It’s impossible to talk about Brooklyn sandwich shops without bringing up Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe. This spot is away from all of the trendy Williamsburg chaos. Clean subway tile lines the walls of the cozy dining area, and knockout fries are served in paper-lined baskets by friendly staff—all to the soundtrack of classic Italian pop hits. Get the chicken parmesan with its perfectly seasoned tomato sauce and a mound of philly steak panini, which are both menu section standouts.
Bread & Spread
$ | (718) 625-2220 | WEBSITE
This cozy sandwich shop in Brooklyn complete with warm lighting, rustic wooden tables, and chalkboard menus is comfort food central. Sandwiches are substantial, porchetta is employed with a generous hand, and the classics—turkey and short rib piled high on fresh bread—require no explanation. You will have leftovers.
Defonte’s Sandwich Shop
$ | (718) 625-8052 | WEBSITE
Just inside the entrance of this Red Hook institution, a sign reads ‘Cash only, no substitutions, no regrets.’ But what this century-old deli does have are legendary sandwiches that live up to their reputation. Begin with the Roast Pork Special piled with provolone and broccoli rabe—the eggplant option makes a satisfying vegetarian alternative too. The sandwiches are truly meals in your hand, so consider splitting one if you’re not ravenous.
The bustling dining area gets lively even during off-hours, so grab a seat by the window if you want to people-watch while you eat. Just remember to bring bills—this classic spot doesn’t mess with plastic.
Royal Rib House NYC
$$ | (718) 453-9284 | WEBSITE
Smoke, sauce, and soul. That’s what a meal at Royal Rib House NYC is all about—this Bed-Stuy spot serves up barbecue with a heaping side of tradition. It’s been a neighborhood classic for years. You can taste the history in every perfectly done rib thanks to the sweet sauce that glazes them, and the comforting sides that come piled high on the plate. And the professional staff remains happy to guide you through the worthy portions.
Get the Barbecue Ribs, scoop up the leftover sauce with the macaroni & cheese, and finish it all off with the incredibly amazing peach cobbler.
Brennan & Carr
$ | (718) 769-1254 | WEBSITE
Brennan & Carr has been around for almost 90 years. The casual spot in Brooklyn is unpretentious charm personified, right down to the simple yet satisfying food you’re greeted with immediately upon ordering. The roast beef sandwiches are solid across the board, but a must is the Gargiulo burger with roast beef, which is delicious and melts like butter as soon as you take a bite.
Jersey Mike’s Subs
$ | (347) 382-6677 | WEBSITE
Jersey Mike’s Subs in Brooklyn is the kind of sandwich spot where a quick pickup feels like a neighborhood ritual—even when it’s your first time. The compact counter-service setup is steps from the scenic street, where staff like Sade chat with regulars who’ve been coming here since the TV spots started airing. They’ll also recommend subs to you based on what you’re craving, including anything from the menu.
If making your own choice, stick to the classics, like the #10 tuna fish sub and save room for sharing since the giant-sized portions can easily feed a small group.