If you’re craving the perfect sandwich in Hayward, here are seven standout shops you need to try this year. From a family-run deli with generations-old recipes to a modern spot reinventing the classic hoagie, these are the places making waves in 2026.
Crave Subs
$ | (510) 780-3809 | WEBSITE
Sometimes, a restaurant gets its name 100% correct. That’s the case for Crave Subs, a sandwich shop in Hayward that offers a wide range of made-to-order sandwiches. The comic book-themed decor is like stepping into a Saturday morning cartoon: colorful, inviting, and crackling with fun. There are three or so uniquely named sandwiches, like the Tom & Jerry with special ingredients, or the Pikachu packed full of flavor. They’re served on fresh Dutch Crunch bread, so expect a satisfying meal.
Ike’s Love & Sandwiches
$ | (510) 397-1690 | WEBSITE
Ike’s Love & Sandwiches is an experience. The Hayward sandwich shop is located in a bustling strip mall, right next to a Costco and across from an Orange Theory. To get here, you have to navigate the crowded parking lot and pass through the glass doors, at which point you’ll find yourself in a compact space with bright yellow walls and sandwich names scrawled in marker on the menu boards.
It’s a lively place, with an equally lively menu that tackles everything from the Matt Cain to the Michael Jordan. Not every sandwich is a home run, but everything is, at the very least, memorably delicious.
Subway
$$ | (510) 429-1709 | WEBSITE
Subway is a popular spot for a 12″ sandwich in Hayward. It’s a straightforward shop with bright lighting and simple decor, where the staff is friendly and amazing, especially towards kids. However, the lack of AC can make it uncomfortably hot inside during warmer months. Despite this, the ladies working there are efficient and make delicious sandwiches, like the club sandwich with turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo for about $8.
The store is clean and the service is good, although not overly friendly. Overall, it’s a great place to satisfy a sandwich craving, even though there are other options available.
Pop’s Deli & Grill
$ | (510) 471-8070 | WEBSITE
When Pop’s Deli & Grill opened in Hayward, they rocked the local sandwich scene with their impressive loaded Tri-Tip, praised for its tenderness and flavor. Their handmade BBQ sauce is also a standout, rivaling any other deli’s offerings. This welcoming spot is a must on any East Bay food crawl. With one of the largest, most interesting selections on their fairly large menu, there’s a little something for everyone.
Erik’s DeliCafé
$ | (510) 876-5555 | WEBSITE
One of the best lunch spots in downtown Hayward, Erik’s DeliCafé serves satisfying sandwiches, like the Farmers Market, and vegetarian options like the Del Monte Special. From the same people behind the catering service, this cafe is a delight—all charming, sunlit, rustic wooden tables—where drinks in glass jars and food on real plates flow along with the friendly service.
For grabbing a quick bite alone, or settling in at a table with coworkers that’s becoming more team than work, Erik’s DeliCafé is the kind of midday retreat that every downtown needs.
Quiznos
$ | (510) 733-5881 | WEBSITE
When Quiznos opened in Hayward, we spent lunch hours wondering what would become of our sandwich cravings. Enter the rosemary parmesan bread. The team behind this spot, with special mention to Anna who always has a smile, serves up delicious sandwiches like tuna with Swiss or the steak sandwich with peppercorn sauce. The space hasn’t changed much, so it might be the only place in the Bay area where you can get a $12 sandwich with a hint of Tex-Mex flavor while enjoying the lively atmosphere.
After you’re done, the clean restaurant and fast service make it perfect for an in-and-out visit, ensuring you leave satisfied with your hearty meal.
TOGO’S Sandwiches
$ | (510) 887-2770 | WEBSITE
From one of the popular spots in the local sandwich scene, Togo’s Sandwiches is a go-to destination in Hayward that has become a favorite for both quick lunches and satisfying meals. The straightforward, welcoming space offers generous portions, courteous service, and great options, like the popular triple French dip sandwich with its ample meat and tasty parmesan bread. When you’re looking for quality without breaking the bank, grab a sandwich that delivers on flavor and value.