Maybe you think you’ve tasted every classic sub and hoagie along the Jersey Shore, or perhaps you’re tired of the same old boardwalk fare. Either way, another basic deli counter isn’t going to satisfy. You need something truly memorable. So head to these Wildwood sandwich shops that stand apart from the rest. A few craft unexpected flavor combinations, some have decades of local lore, and a couple you’ll just need to taste to believe.
SHAWN’S CHEESESTEAKS & PANINIS
$ | (609) 551-2985 | WEBSITE
Whenever we need a break from the boardwalk bustle, we make our way to Shawn’s Cheesesteaks & Paninis. Tucked away in a simple storefront that feels like a classic Jersey shore joint, Shawn’s exudes a no-frills authenticity that reminds us of the old-school sandwich shops we grew up with, except there’s no compromise on quality here.
The cheesesteak-packed menu includes tender, well-seasoned beef on fresh rolls, creative twists like the scrapple cheesesteak, and something called a chicken cheesesteak that lives up to its reputation. Expect to see generous portions and friendly service that make every visit worthwhile.
Five Girls Sandwich Shop
$ | (609) 554-3925 | WEBSITE
A lunch at Five Girls Sandwich Shop is like stepping into a classic Jersey shore diner, if it were designed by someone who really, really loves sandwiches. In other words, it’s pure comfort. If you’re in the market for a straightforward, value-packed meal, though, Five Girls is the best deal in town. You’ll see families sharing fries, kids happily digging into their well-portioned meals, and everyone chatting over generously filled hoagies.
Servers will greet you with genuine smiles and keep things moving efficiently, and you’ll eat perfectly priced sandwiches like the top-notch cheesesteak or the fresh BLT that taste exactly like a great sandwich should. The food is consistently good, and it’s so satisfying that it enhances the relaxed atmosphere, which is why you’ll definitely be back.
PrimoHoagies
$ | (609) 368-8600 | WEBSITE
The phrase ‘fast food’ gets thrown around a lot these days, but truly, in this fast-paced world, a place like PrimoHoagies is a revelation. The Italian Sharp Prevaleone at this sandwich shop is no longer a secret, but at $12.50 each, it’s still a steal. Plus, they include the most thoughtful touch for free: cutting it in half without asking. The level of freshness in your sandwich is guaranteed, but take our advice and don’t underestimate the quick service.
Most days, PrimoHoagies feels like one clean, organized neighborhood gem.
Mel’s Place
$ | (609) 600-3286 | WEBSITE
If you’re not satisfied with your breakfast at Mel’s Place, you might just be too picky. This cozy local diner tucked away in Wildwood has plenty of charm—checkered tablecloths, friendly chatter filling the air, and the comforting smell of coffee and bacon, to name a few—but the most charming part is the straightforward, no-fuss approach to morning classics.
Order the highly recommended Eggs Benedict or a Florentine omelet for around $12 and you’re presented with a generous plate of perfectly cooked food, then left to enjoy it in the warm, inviting atmosphere. The rest is up to you to savor. Are there fancier breakfast spots around? Sure, but they’re not this welcoming to start your day.
Cape May Peanut Butter Co.
$ | (609) 898-4444 | WEBSITE
We were born too late to explore the globe, and born too early to explore the universe, but at least we were born in time to experience the whimsical peanut butter paradise at Cape May Peanut Butter Co. Located in the heart of Wildwood, this charming shop has you sample from dozens of jars, then purchase your favorites to take home (a common setup in artisanal food shops). The peanut butter here is a notch or two above your average grocery store spread, but it’s still very affordable.
Prioritize the strawberry and butterscotch flavors and fun peanut butter hot cocoa.
Westside Market
$ | (609) 884-3061 | WEBSITE
For a ‘sandwich paradise’ kind of lunch that hits all the right notes, there’s no place quite like Westside Market. This beloved Cape May spot takes up a cozy corner in West Cape May, and just walking in feels like an event. First, you’re greeted by the welcoming staff who treat every customer exceptionally well, and then you’re surrounded by the butcher block and phenomenal bread selection.
You could very well enjoy a cheesesteak considered one of the best outside of Philadelphia, then grab a homemade baked good that’s to die for in the same visit. We suggest starting with the castaway cutlet or meaty ball sandwich, then trying the out-of-this-world prepared food sandwiches and fries. Just be aware that you’ll want to save room for their exceptional breakfast burritos and phenomenal salads too.
Mad D’s Muncheonette
$ | (609) 830-3691 | WEBSITE
Every visit to Mad D’s Muncheonette begins the same way: a classic Jersey cheesesteak is assembled with meticulous care behind the counter, then handed over in a simple paper wrapper with a warm smile. Then you take your first bite. For the most part, the cheesesteak here tastes as good as it looks, especially with its excellent quality and attention to detail. It’s also a solid bargain.
The cheesesteaks are available at three different price points—$12, $15, or $18—but the cheapest option already delivers a highly satisfactory experience.