Even as Brooklyn’s culinary scene evolves at breakneck speed, the classic steakhouse remains its beating heart. Just a subway ride away (barring delays, of course), these temples of beef offer dark wood ambiance, martinis that bite back, and the primal satisfaction of a perfectly charred ribeye. While the borough’s dining landscape constantly shifts, these 14 stalwarts continue to serve timeless excellence. If you’re craving that singular carnivorous experience, here’s where to find it.
Peter Luger Steak House
$$$$ | (718) 387-7400 | WEBSITE
Open for dinner only, Peter Luger is an iconic steakhouse in Brooklyn, and a must-visit destination for anyone craving a classic American meal. That said, their legendary Porterhouse steak is our thing here, and at around $150 for two, it’s also an investment worth making. They’ve maintained their straightforward, no-frills dining room to ensure the focus remains squarely on the food. Bring cash and be prepared for the mandatory service charge.
The King Of Meat
$$ | (718) 489-9084 | WEBSITE
Certain expectations come with a Brooklyn steakhouse, like perfectly cooked cuts and a lively atmosphere, but the family-friendly vibe at The King of Meat in Sunset pleasantly surprised us. This spot is a neighborhood favorite, offering immensely satisfying versions of all the steakhouse essentials like a boneless ribeye cooked to perfection and a bone-in ribeye served on a Himalayan salt block.
The restaurant features comfy booths and stools, great lighting, and excellent music, making it ideal for a quiet night out with friends or as a pre-drink spot. Both the indoor dining and accommodating service create a welcoming experience for all.
Bordeaux Steakhouse
$$$$ | (718) 942-4040 | WEBSITE
Bordeaux Steakhouse might not have the trendy vibe of other Brooklyn steakhouses, but when you’re in the mood for a classic steakhouse experience without any gimmicks, you can’t beat it. The upscale restaurant has a focused menu featuring every steakhouse staple you could want – aged ribeye, Tomahawk steaks, lamb chops, and our favorite lemon tart and chocolate souffle in town. They currently offer impeccable service with a great sense of humor and a pleasant ambiance with quiet background music.
Patrick Steakhouse
$$$ | (347) 789-9976 | WEBSITE
Before the pandemic, Patrick Steakhouse was unquestionably the place to be for dinner if you were in town for a celebration. Obviously, things have changed a bit, but the cozy steakhouse in Brooklyn has reopened for socially distant outdoor dining on their charming patio. Just be sure to take it slow with their tasty drinks – they’ll catch up to you in a hurry. Call for reservations to experience their perfect cooking and lively atmosphere.
Glatt A La Carte
$$$$ | (718) 438-6675 | WEBSITE
If you hear someone mention “steak!” in Brooklyn, it probably means they’re headed to Glatt A La Carte. Open for dinner every evening, this kosher restaurant has become the go-to destination for quality meat in the borough, and maintains a warm and inviting ambiance that makes every meal feel special. They don’t take reservations for smaller parties, but even on busy nights, it’s wise to arrive early to secure a table. The beef carpaccio is a must.
Butcher Grill House
$$$ | (347) 770-4042 | WEBSITE
Located in the heart of Brooklyn, Butcher Grill House has quickly become one of our favorite steakhouse destinations with a consistently excellent menu that’s always full of the things you want to eat while celebrating a special occasion. Think expertly prepared skirt steaks, delmonico cuts, and beef skewers. The interior is currently as warm and inviting as ever, with elegant surroundings that make every meal feel like an event.
The entire menu is available in the welcoming dining room, where families gather and the attentive, solution-oriented staff ensures a flawless experience from start to finish.
Jerusalem Steak House II
$$$ | (718) 258-8899 | WEBSITE
With a family-friendly Middle Eastern steakhouse vibe, Jerusalem Steak House II is a welcoming, unpretentious spot and perhaps your best opportunity to finally enjoy that hearty meal you’ve been craving. This is a solid dining experience (and a pretty good one at that), but with generous portion sizes and a relaxed atmosphere that allows for plenty of room to spread out with friends. Call ahead to make sure they’re open for lunch.
Libertador
$$$ | (347) 689-3122 | WEBSITE
Open for several years now, Libertador remains a charming and cozy spot in Brooklyn’s dining scene, but its Argentine-inspired food deserves your attention. The menu is quite focused, but whether you go for the mixed grill with different meats, the flavorful empanadas, or one of the perfectly cooked steak platters, know that you’re going to be eating – and drinking – well. The interior has been thoughtfully decorated to enhance the peaceful ambiance.
GOSHT | Restaurant | Halal Steakhouse & Burgers
$$ | (718) 504-8880 | WEBSITE
If you’ve heard of one halal steakhouse in Brooklyn, chances are it’s GOSHT. This family-friendly restaurant right in the neighborhood is largely credited for bringing the whole halal steakhouse experience to the borough. And even after all these years – and plenty of new competition – it’s still one of the best.
Their large play area with slides is open during regular dining hours, creating a welcoming atmosphere where the friendly staff makes everyone feel at home while enjoying dishes like dumplings, bone marrow, chicken fettuccine, lamb rack, and steak sandwiches.
Amber Steak House
$$$$ | (718) 389-3757 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in a prime Brooklyn location, Amber Steak House has been a neighborhood favorite for years now, and while you might find more adventurous dishes elsewhere in the borough, nobody can argue their Porterhouse for two is exceptional. And these days, the dining room feels even more inviting with its relaxing ambience and plenty of space between tables.
Hunter’s Steak & Ale House
$$ | (718) 238-8899 | WEBSITE
Most steakhouses in Brooklyn can feel overly formal, but Hunter’s Steak & Ale House is a welcome exception. The classic dining room has cozy booths, warm lighting, and a meat-focused menu that’ll satisfy any carnivorous craving. Open nightly with valet parking available.
Flatiron Steakhouse – Park Slope
$$$ | (718) 965-4000 | WEBSITE
Tucked away in Park Slope, you could easily mistake Flatiron Steakhouse for a classic steakhouse, but it is, in fact, a restaurant. And a great one at that. The menu is focused, with everything from pork belly starters to tomahawk steaks to poblano mac and cheese, but just know you can’t really order wrong here. There’s a dimly lit interior with comfortable cloth chairs, attentive service, and plenty of atmosphere.
Prestige Steakhouse
$$$ | (718) 971-1106 | WEBSITE
Located in the heart of Brooklyn, Prestige Steakhouse looks and feels like any other upscale steakhouse, but the food here is much better than that. Open for dinner service, Prestige Steakhouse has a very solid menu full of perfectly cooked steaks, seafood salad, lobster ravioli, and other very tasty things. Their outdoor patio is a great place to relax with friends before it gets too chilly out.
The Loft Steakhouse
$$$$ | (718) 475-5600 | WEBSITE
Most people probably don’t head into Brooklyn expecting to find a world-class kosher steakhouse, but The Loft Steakhouse continues to prove that theory wrong. This high-end spot in Borough Park has steaks that go toe-to-toe with some restaurants in Manhattan, so if you’re looking for a romantic dinner and beautifully designed private party rooms, keep The Loft top of mind. The cowboy steak and soft brisket are both musts. Be prepared for a wait even with reservations.